By Jonathan Cook
Znet
"Jonathan Cook has been covering the Israeli-Palestinian conflict from Nazareth, Israel, as a freelance reporter for the past eight years. Before that he was a staff journalist at the Guardian and Observer newspapers. His latest books on the conflict are ‘Israel and the Clash of Civilisations' (Pluto, 2008) and ‘Disappearing Palestine' (Zed, 2008). His website is www.jkcook.net
In the Guest Media Alert that follows, Cook attempts the truly Herculean task of dissecting and comparing the key arguments in Nick Davies's book ‘Flat Earth News' and our own recently published ‘Newspeak in the 21st Century.' The results are enthralling but demanding - even hardened media analysts will require a plentiful supply of tea and biscuits throughout.
Please do not underestimate the unique nature of the analysis Cook is offering. While Davies's book was discussed, reviewed, and applauded, far and wide in both print and broadcast media, our own book (published in September) has so far limped to just two, largely dismissive, reviews in mainstream outlets, in the Guardian and Times Higher Education (THE), totalling exactly 1,000 words. Our previous book, Guardians of Power (2006), has never been mentioned, let alone reviewed, in any mainstream national UK newspaper.
The truth is that dissident media analyses are consistently ignored in this way - it is not just us. And so Cook's comparison of Davies's mainstream view of the media with an analysis based on Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky's "propaganda model of media control" is a vanishingly rare event. As ever, Cook's experience as a professional journalist adds a fascinating additional dimension to his analysis.
Cook produced this mega-review - nearly 10,000 words of it - completely free of charge. It is an extraordinary act of generosity from a fine and thoughtful journalist. We would like to express our sincere thanks to him. If you would like to thank him or otherwise comment, you can write to him here: mail@jkcook.net
The Two Books:
Nick Davies, Flat Earth News, Vintage 2008, pp. 420
David Edwards and David Cromwell, Newspeak in the 21st Century, Pluto Press 2009, pp. 299......
Conclusion
There is much that Davies' and Edwards and Cromwell's books share: both view the media as essentially a corporate media; both dismiss the idea of objective journalism as a nonsense and agree that journalists must, and do, take sides; and both regard the media's reporting as an unreliable guide to what is really happening in the world. But on the issue of the causes of this wholesale failure, a gulf separates them.
One day we may not need newspapers - certainly we may not need ones tied to corporate interests that depend on advertising and our ever-greater reliance on air flights and luxury cars that are destroying the planet. In an era of profound economic and ideological crisis, our media's inability properly to address these problems makes Davies' book begin to look like an excessively indulgent excuse for this failure. Edwards and Cromwell's book, by contrast, seems to have much greater power to explain the strangely consistent blind-spots from which our media suffer.
I was once a journalist of the Davies' school, believing that our media enjoyed an inalienable freedom both to get it right and, as often, to get it wrong. The disturbing conclusions reached by Edwards and Cromwell are easier for me to accept today in part because I have spent so long in Israel, an overtly ideological and ruthlessly colonial society whose leaders have so transparently co-opted their own media. Israeli journalists, even of the most liberal variety, have been recruited to the task of mobilising local Jewish public opinion in the pursuit of racial goals, such as maintaining Israel's ethnic purity, that are shocking to an outsider but go unquestioned by the overwhelming majority of Israeli Jews. Israeli journalists are as blind to the idea that they are manufacturing consent for an aggressive ethnic state as journalists like Davies are to the idea that their role is to prop up a political and economic system that benefits corporate
power.
It is precisely Davies' intimate familiarity with the British media that makes him a fascinating but ultimately unreliable companion as he surveys the media's role. In this case, outsiders like Edwards and Cromwell prove the more useful guides."
Znet
"Jonathan Cook has been covering the Israeli-Palestinian conflict from Nazareth, Israel, as a freelance reporter for the past eight years. Before that he was a staff journalist at the Guardian and Observer newspapers. His latest books on the conflict are ‘Israel and the Clash of Civilisations' (Pluto, 2008) and ‘Disappearing Palestine' (Zed, 2008). His website is www.jkcook.net
In the Guest Media Alert that follows, Cook attempts the truly Herculean task of dissecting and comparing the key arguments in Nick Davies's book ‘Flat Earth News' and our own recently published ‘Newspeak in the 21st Century.' The results are enthralling but demanding - even hardened media analysts will require a plentiful supply of tea and biscuits throughout.
Please do not underestimate the unique nature of the analysis Cook is offering. While Davies's book was discussed, reviewed, and applauded, far and wide in both print and broadcast media, our own book (published in September) has so far limped to just two, largely dismissive, reviews in mainstream outlets, in the Guardian and Times Higher Education (THE), totalling exactly 1,000 words. Our previous book, Guardians of Power (2006), has never been mentioned, let alone reviewed, in any mainstream national UK newspaper.
The truth is that dissident media analyses are consistently ignored in this way - it is not just us. And so Cook's comparison of Davies's mainstream view of the media with an analysis based on Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky's "propaganda model of media control" is a vanishingly rare event. As ever, Cook's experience as a professional journalist adds a fascinating additional dimension to his analysis.
Cook produced this mega-review - nearly 10,000 words of it - completely free of charge. It is an extraordinary act of generosity from a fine and thoughtful journalist. We would like to express our sincere thanks to him. If you would like to thank him or otherwise comment, you can write to him here: mail@jkcook.net
The Two Books:
Nick Davies, Flat Earth News, Vintage 2008, pp. 420
David Edwards and David Cromwell, Newspeak in the 21st Century, Pluto Press 2009, pp. 299......
Conclusion
There is much that Davies' and Edwards and Cromwell's books share: both view the media as essentially a corporate media; both dismiss the idea of objective journalism as a nonsense and agree that journalists must, and do, take sides; and both regard the media's reporting as an unreliable guide to what is really happening in the world. But on the issue of the causes of this wholesale failure, a gulf separates them.
One day we may not need newspapers - certainly we may not need ones tied to corporate interests that depend on advertising and our ever-greater reliance on air flights and luxury cars that are destroying the planet. In an era of profound economic and ideological crisis, our media's inability properly to address these problems makes Davies' book begin to look like an excessively indulgent excuse for this failure. Edwards and Cromwell's book, by contrast, seems to have much greater power to explain the strangely consistent blind-spots from which our media suffer.
I was once a journalist of the Davies' school, believing that our media enjoyed an inalienable freedom both to get it right and, as often, to get it wrong. The disturbing conclusions reached by Edwards and Cromwell are easier for me to accept today in part because I have spent so long in Israel, an overtly ideological and ruthlessly colonial society whose leaders have so transparently co-opted their own media. Israeli journalists, even of the most liberal variety, have been recruited to the task of mobilising local Jewish public opinion in the pursuit of racial goals, such as maintaining Israel's ethnic purity, that are shocking to an outsider but go unquestioned by the overwhelming majority of Israeli Jews. Israeli journalists are as blind to the idea that they are manufacturing consent for an aggressive ethnic state as journalists like Davies are to the idea that their role is to prop up a political and economic system that benefits corporate
power.
It is precisely Davies' intimate familiarity with the British media that makes him a fascinating but ultimately unreliable companion as he surveys the media's role. In this case, outsiders like Edwards and Cromwell prove the more useful guides."
ativan online ativan side effects bipolar - order ativan online no prescription
ReplyDeletecheap generic ativan ativan reviews - ativan kidney damage
ReplyDeletetramadol online is buying tramadol online legal - buy tramadol cod
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol cash on delivery tramadol kidney disease - tramadol withdrawal symptoms and duration
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin stevie nicks klonopin weight gain - 2mg of klonopin and alcohol
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online ultram online no prescription - buy ultram online uk
ReplyDeletegeneric tramadol online is it legal to order tramadol on line' - buy cheap tramadol cod
ReplyDeleteorder tramadol buy cheap tramadol usa - tramadol no prescription overnight cod delivery
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol no rx buy tramadol online no prescription next day delivery - tramadol 50mg tablets an 627
ReplyDeleteklonopin 2mg klonopin high duration - klonopin rash
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol 100mg online - buy tramadol faq
ReplyDeleteklonopin online pharmacy klonopin overdose side effects - buy clonazepam online no prescription cheap
ReplyDeletebuy ambien online without prescription trazodone ambien insomnia - ambien side effects sleep driving
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online tramadol online legal - order tramadol online overnight
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol 50mg does it get you high - buy tramadol mastercard
ReplyDeletegeneric ambien ambien drug wikipedia - ambien side effects hot flashes
ReplyDeletepurchase tramadol order tramadol online international - tramadol 50mg tablets info
ReplyDeletebuy klonopin online no prescription klonopin zoloft anxiety - klonopin does cause weight gain
ReplyDeleteonline soma soma san diego sidestage - buy soma fedex
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol ultram buy tramadol online overnight delivery - can you buy tramadol over counter
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online reviews tramadol online pharmacy - tramadol 50mg my dog
ReplyDeletewhere to buy ambien online buy ambien usa - kind drug ambien cr
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol next day tramadol dosage dogs cancer - tramadol hcl tab 50mg
ReplyDeletesoma online pharmacy soma muscle relaxer with alcohol - soma san diego tribal seeds
ReplyDeletetramadol online cod purchase tramadol cod - online-viagra-tramadol.com
ReplyDeletebuy ambien online side effects of ambien cr and alcohol - ambien 10 mg
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol without rx tramadol ultracet dosage - buy generic tramadol online
ReplyDeletebuy ambien online buy ambien drug - ambien side effects bruising
ReplyDeletebuy soma buy soma no rx - soma san diego a day to remember
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online no prescription tramadol dosage weight - zydol tramadol dosage
ReplyDeleteorder clonazepam klonopin 4mg day - klonopin side effects night sweats
ReplyDeletebuy ambien no prescription 10mg ambien price - difference between zolpidem ambien cr
ReplyDeleteklonopin pill klonopin for quitting smoking - 2mg klonopin equal
ReplyDeletewhere to buy tramadol online uss cheap tramadol - order tramadol without
ReplyDeletetramadol tramadol 50 mg is used to treat - tramadol online cheap no prescription
ReplyDeleteklonopin buy klonopin withdrawal jaw pain - generic klonopin 2mg
ReplyDeletegeneric tramadol online can you buy tramadol over counter - is it legal to buy tramadol online uk
ReplyDeletebuy ambien online no prescription ambien dose - ambien walrus kill your parents
ReplyDeleteviagra without prescription can u buy viagra online - order brand viagra online
ReplyDeleteviagra online buy viagra at cvs - purchase viagra online pharmacy
ReplyDeleteklonopin for anxiety klonopin blackout - klonopin 2mg price
ReplyDeleteambien no rx buy ambien walmart - difference between zolpidem ambien cr
ReplyDeletebuy generic klonopin bad take 2mg klonopin - klonopin vs xanax erowid
ReplyDeleteviagra online does generic viagra work forum - buy viagra online with paypal
ReplyDeleteonline soma soma drug book - minimizer bras soma
ReplyDeletebuy ambien online ambien overdose toxicology - ambien side effects the next day
ReplyDeletetramadol online tramadol hcl vicodin - tramadol without prescription
ReplyDeletebuy zolpidem online legal to buy ambien online - ambien side effects sleepwalking
ReplyDeletebuy viagra toronto viagra online singapore - viagra robin williams
ReplyDeleteorder viagra for women safe to buy generic viagra online - viagra buy online uk
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol no rx buy tramadol overnight - buy tramadol online from india
ReplyDeletegeneric soma online soma kendrick - jeffree star soma san diego
ReplyDeletebuy viagra cheap how to purchase viagra in canada - generic viagra pictures
ReplyDeletebuy viagra online cheap generic viagra online pharmacy - purchase viagra online safely
ReplyDeletecialis online generic cialis no prescription canada - trusted online pharmacy cialis
ReplyDeletegeneric soma online soma saga - soma prescription pills
ReplyDeletehow to order viagra online safely buying viagra in uk - viagra rite aid
ReplyDeleteorder viagra online buy viagra for women - buy viagra online laser card
ReplyDeletecialis 20mg price for cialis 5mg - cialis price 20mg
ReplyDeletebuy viagra buy viagra online toronto - buy viagra online in canada
ReplyDeletebuy viagra best online generic viagra site - buy viagra vegas
ReplyDeletebuy viagra online pharmacy viagra gel for women uk - viagra to buy online uk
ReplyDeletegeneric soma online buy generic soma online - where to buy aura-soma products
ReplyDeleteviagra online viagra from canada online - viagra buy uk online
ReplyDeletetramadol online generic brand for tramadol - get high tramadol 50mg
ReplyDeletebuy viagra buy generic viagra online canada - buy viagra online tesco
ReplyDeletebuy viagra online legally how to purchase viagra in uk - viagra vasodilator
ReplyDeletepropecia online propecia side effects hypertension - can i buy propecia in japan
ReplyDeleteorder viagra now viagra what does it do - viagra user reviews
ReplyDeletewhere to buy tramadol ways get high tramadol - tramadol high cholesterol
ReplyDeleteorder tramadol online without prescription take tramadol 50 mg get high - tramadol dosage 100mg
ReplyDeletewhere to order viagra viagra quick tabs - generic viagra online canadian pharmacy
ReplyDeletetramadol no rx tramadol for dogs 100mg - buy tramadol rx online
ReplyDeletediscount propecia cheapest way to buy propecia - buy propecia canada online
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol cod next day delivery tramadol brand name ultram - buy tramadol cod personal check
ReplyDeletebuy propecia online dr reddy's generic propecia - propecia infertility
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online tramadol 99.95 - tramadol zydus 50 mg
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online without a prescription tramadol for anxiety - tramadol hcl vicodin
ReplyDeletepropecia cost propecia wiki - safest place buy propecia
ReplyDeletebuy propecia online propecia 60 minutes - propecia results after one month
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol buy tramadol without rx - tramadol high length
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol no prescription tramadol hcl no prescription - tramadol high booze
ReplyDeletetramadol online cheap 100mg tramadol - tramadol 50 mg canine
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol without rx buy tramadol online with echeck - tramadol hcl for dogs
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online cod overnight tramadol schedule - purchase tramadol generic ultram
ReplyDeletetramadol without prescription tramadol for dogs dose - safe place buy tramadol online
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online buy tramadol online new zealand - high on tramadol
ReplyDeletetramadol 50mg tramadol withdrawal ease - tramadol 50mg like
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online buy tramadol online forum - tramadolonlinepharmacy
ReplyDeletebuy propecia online best site to order propecia - can you buy propecia online no prescription
ReplyDeletepropecia cost generic propecia in usa - is it safe to buy propecia online
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol rx tramadol (ultram) shelf life - tramadol hcl vs tramadol
ReplyDeletebuy atomoxetine online strattera side effects skin rash - strattera becoming generic
ReplyDeletepurchase retin-a buy retin a 1.0 - retin-a lotion
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol back pain - tramadol high heart rate
ReplyDeletecheap generic propecia can you buy propecia dubai - dr reddy's generic propecia
ReplyDeletetramadol 50 tramadol overdose much fatal - tramadol trade name generic name
ReplyDeletewhere to buy tramadol where to buy tramadol online safely - side effects for tramadol 50mg
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol next day legal purchase tramadol online - buy cheap tramadol online
ReplyDeletetramadol 50mg tramadol for migraines - tramadol for dogs different than for humans
ReplyDeletebuy propecia propecia cost at costco - propecia generic discount
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online tramadol for dogs same as humans - tramadol 50mg side effects
ReplyDeletetramadol online tramadol for dogs 100mg - buy tramadol online without script
ReplyDeleteorder tramadol tramadol ultram same medication - buy tramadol online worldwide
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol cod next day delivery cheap generic tramadol - tramadol 50mg tablets an 627
ReplyDeletegeneric viagra inurl dsa.gov.us buy viagra - buy viagra online us no prescription
ReplyDeleteviagra online without prescription cheap viagra au - viagra buy online us
ReplyDeletecheap viagra buy viagra online reviews - purchase viagra in london
ReplyDeletebuy cialis 36 hour cialis online - generic cialis efficacy
ReplyDeletebuy generic viagra anyone ever buy viagra online - buy generic viagra us
ReplyDeletebuy generic cialis buy cialis online no prescription canada - cialis coupon trial offer
ReplyDeletecheap generic cialis cialis online us pharmacy - buy generic viagra cialis online
ReplyDeletehow to buy cialis cialis online coupon - cialis online no prescription canadian pharmacy
ReplyDeleteviagra online without prescription buy viagra online legally - viagra for women gel
ReplyDeletediscount viagra viagra online store us - viagra 150 mg dose
ReplyDeletecheapest cialis buy cialis philippines - how to buy cialis online uk
ReplyDeletediscount viagra buy viagra online paypal - black king generic viagra
ReplyDeletegeneric viagra safe buy viagra online forum - buy generic viagra with paypal
ReplyDeletegeneric viagra does online generic viagra work - safe viagra online orders
ReplyDeleteviagra cost order generic viagra us - buy viagra cheap online no prescription
ReplyDeletebuy cialis can you buy cialis online no prescription - generic cialis fda approved
ReplyDeletegeneric cialis cheap cialis in uk - buy cialis 10mg
ReplyDeleteorder cialis generic cialis in australia - cialis листовка
ReplyDeletecialis no prescription generic cialis available us - cialis vs tadalafil
ReplyDeletetadalafil no prescription buy cialis daily use - buy cialis online canadian pharmacy
ReplyDeletebuy cialis buy cialis online safely - how to order cialis online safely
ReplyDeletesoma medication soma skeletal muscle motor neurons - buy soma us
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online tramadol online topix - tramadol for dogs 10 mg
ReplyDeletegeneric viagra online cheap viagra us sale - purchase viagra us
ReplyDeleteviagra online generic viagra new zealand - buy viagra online new york
ReplyDeletesoma no prescription soma quill riser - where to buy sumatriptan injections
ReplyDeletebuy cialis buy cialis soft tabs - buy cialis online with no prescription
ReplyDeletebuy soma online soma medication migraines - muscle relaxer stronger than soma
ReplyDeletebuy cialis xlpharmacy generic cialis - cialis online paypal
ReplyDeleteviagra pills buy viagra in germany - order viagra in south africa
ReplyDeletebuy soma online soma pills in brave new world - discontinued soma bras
ReplyDeletecarisoprodol soma generic name for soma compound - soma drug hindu
ReplyDeletebuy soma soma san diego pierce the veil - what does soma drug do
ReplyDeletebuy soma muscle relaxant soma carisoprodol - soma muscle relaxer while pregnant
ReplyDeletebuy soma online soma pills 446 - aura soma online test
ReplyDeletebuy retin a can i buy retin a cream over the counter - retin a micro ingredients
ReplyDeletebuy soma online buy serostim somatropin - buy soma from usa
ReplyDeletebuy generic soma soma 700 mg dose - soma online pharmacy no prescription
ReplyDeletesoma no prescription buy somatropin injection - soma wellness boulder
ReplyDeletebuy retin-a retin a week 1 - where to buy retin-a usa
ReplyDeletebuy retin a retin a micro gel generic - retin a micro night cream
ReplyDeletecialis online no prescription buy cialis online australia - generic cialis line
ReplyDeletebuy cheap soma soma san diego theater - soma online coupon codes
ReplyDeletebuy soma online soma on drug test - soma pill v
ReplyDeletebuy soma soma by nature - buy generic soma online
ReplyDeleteorder tramadol online overnight order tramadol cheap - tramadol 50 mg every 4 hours
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol hydrochloride buy online - ok take 2 50mg tramadol
ReplyDeletewhere to buy retin-a online retin a micro online - retin-a cream burn
ReplyDeletebuy retin a retin a micro gel pump reviews - retin-a gel hair loss
ReplyDeletebuy retin a retin a cream dry skin - retin a cream nhs
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol hcl 325 - buy generic ultram online
ReplyDeleteretin a online coupon for retin a micro gel - retin a cream 0.05 20g buy
ReplyDeletetramadol cheap buy ultram online cheap - get ultram online
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online tramadol for cheap - buy tramadol online co.usa
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol cash on delivery buy tramadol hydrochloride - high does tramadol get you
ReplyDeletecialis online generic cialis paypal - buy cheap generic cialis online
ReplyDeletetramadol 50 where to buy tramadol - tramadol online no prescription fedex
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol online with mastercard where to buy ultram - tramadol hcl hydrocodone
ReplyDeletegeneric xanax xanax recreational drug use - xanax and 2 mg day
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol hcl recreational dose - buy tramadol usa
ReplyDeleteorder xanax false negative drug test xanax - buy xanax no prescription mastercard
ReplyDeletetramadol 50 what is tramadol 50mg tablets used for - legal buy tramadol online us
ReplyDeletetramadol online tramadol 50 mg - where to buy tramadol online
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol tramadol dosage instructions - tramadol 50 mg purchase
ReplyDeletebuy tramadol with mastercard buy tramadol online with mastercard - buy tramadol overnight saturday delivery
ReplyDeletebuy carisoprodol soma carisoprodol 250 mg - soma carisoprodol tablets used
ReplyDeletediscount xanax xanax 0.25 high - xanax overdose amount alcohol
ReplyDeletetramadol online tramadol for dogs without rx - buy tramadol egypt
ReplyDeletecialis online usa order cialis no prescription online - reviews for generic cialis
ReplyDeletegeneric tadalafil where to buy cheap cialis - buy cialis online consultation
ReplyDeletetadalafil no prescription cialis glaucoma - generic cialis online pharmacy
ReplyDeletehttp://landvoicelearning.com/#21906 buy tramadol online in europe - tramadol hcl blood pressure
ReplyDeleteclonazepam drug 2mg of klonopin - klonopin dosage options
ReplyDelete