Thursday, January 22, 2009

AN INTERVIEW WITH THE VERY TALENTED CARTOONIST, KHALIL BENDIB

It gives me great pleasure to introduce the very talented political cartoonist Khalil Bendib. As you could easily tell, he is one of my favorite cartoonists. A daily visit to his web site is a must for me, and he has been gracious to let me post his cartoons, as soon as they appear, on Palestinian Pundit (PP).

I apologize to Khalil and to our readers for the delay in publishing this interview, which was conducted by emails. I originally hoped to have the interview ready about 15 days ago, but the horrific attacks on Gaza and all the time I have been spending updating the blog and trying to keep up with all the news, comments, protests, etc have caused this delay.


Many of our readers who admire Khalil’s work have been asking questions about him and some had not heard of him before seeing his cartoons here. So, I was delighted when he agreed to have this interview which will give all of us a better idea who this highly creative cartoonist is. Khalil was kind enough to supply a photograph for this interview.

His most recent book of cartoons, Mission Accomplished, has garnered great reviews by the likes of Ralph Nader, Cynthia McKinney, Publishers Weekly, among many others. You can check it out at http://www.bendib.com/book/

PP: Please give us a brief biographic introduction

Khalil: I was born during the famous Battle of Algiers some 50 + years ago, into the worst possible war atmosphere, which gave me my instinctive identification with all oppressed people in the world in general, and with the Palestinians in particular. My family barely escaped being wiped out by the French and I was born a war refugee. I had two uncles who were tortured by the French, one of whom died of it, but then, not one Algerian family was spared in those years. One and a half million Algerians perished in the genocidal war waged by the French colonial state against the natives of Algeria. We Algerians feel the nightmare of colonialism continues, unabated, in Palestine, under “new management”... And we can’t accept it.


PP: How long have you been doing political cartoons? Do you do other types of cartoons: Comics? Commercial?

Khalil: My first drawings as a kid (3 years old,) were of courageous Algerian soldiers saluting the banned Algerian flag. I was already obsessed with politics. So I think I was ALWAYS a political cartoonist, in a way...


PP: Your cartoons appear in Muslim Observer and Corp Watch; where else?

Khalil: They appear in over 1,700 small and mid-size newspapers across the country, all those small enough to be “under the radar.” They also occasionally appear in the New York Times, USA Today, LA Times and other large papers. But large corporate newspapers can’t really stand me, because my cartoons point out their lies and propaganda. Among my regular clients are many Muslim newspapers, Black newspapers, progressive and environmental magazines, and web sites. Minuteman Media News Service is the news service that distributes my cartoons weekly to 1,700 papers.


PP: Do you always use black and white in your cartoons? Why?

Khalil: I only do them in color if my clients specifically ask for color (Corpwatch, mostly). It takes more time to color them and it isn’t necessary in 99% of the papers, which have strictly black and white editorial pages.


PP: What is your political philosophy/ ideology?

Khalil: I don’t like to pigeonhole or typecast myself and I am critical of ALL narrow ideologies. Being from a Third World, Arab Muslim country but living in the West, in the belly of the imperial beast so to speak, I’m able to see political events from both sides of the issues. That is, with both eyes, which gives me a well-rounded perspective, whereas most of my colleagues in the US are blind in one eye and only see things with their Western, Eurocentric eye.


PP: If there is one unifying theme, what is your message in the cartoons? What do you hope to achieve?

Khalil: Denouncing injustice and hypocrisy would be the common, underlying theme to most of my cartoons. Pointing out the yawning gap between the official discourse (the propaganda) and the actual deeds, which usually fly in the face of the rhetoric. Palestine is the perfect example: the gap between the Zionist lies according to which Israel is the eternal victim and their genocidal deeds and policies against the native Palestinians. Since 99% of our media is helping to spread that propaganda, I see it as my special duty and mission to debunk those lies. The same thing with Islamophobia, etc... And, sadly, I’m the only one in North America who dares to do that. All other cartoonists are either asleep at the wheel or complicit.


PP: Can you amplify on your cartoons in defense of Islam and standing up against attacks on Muslims?

Khalil: Islmaophobia has replaced anti-Semitism (ironically, many Zionist Jews now are the leaders of this old form of hatred called anti-Semitism, and it is now directed against Muslims and Arabs instead.) Since no other cartoonist in this country dares or bothers to denounce this horrible form of discrimination and vilification, it makes it, by default, my job to ring the alarm.


PP: Your cartoons about the post 9/11 US; can you amplify on those? Attacks on Arabs and Muslims, loss of civil liberties, fear mongering, etc.

Khalil: Muslims and Arabs are only the most recent scapegoats in a long line of historically oppressed groups (Blacks, native Americans, Latinos, etc...) We are now the preferred “other” or “enemy,” for obvious reasons: our old countries are vulnerable and ripe for the taking. Witness what happens in Palestine, Iraq, Lebanon, Afghanistan, etc. But that weakness is only temporary, and eventually, no amount of military might or media propaganda will be enough to subdue those populations much longer. In the meantime, it is our job, here in the US, to make as many of our fellow Americans aware of what is truly happening, to educate the world, in order to hasten the demise of injustice and oppression.


PP: Your cartoons in defense of Palestine and the Palestinians; can you amplify on them?

Khalil: Just like the Algerians and so many others before them, the Palestinian people are a heroic people who will, after many painful sacrifices, prevail in the end and win back their land and their freedom. This is not the first time they have been occupied: Remember the Crusades? In the end they will triumph, there is no possible doubt about that. The only question is at what cost, sadly, as we can see before our very eyes in Gaza, as we do this interview.


PP: How recent is your experience with the Arab/ Muslim world? Have you lived or traveled there recently?

Khalil: I have never lost touch with my native North Africa. I go back to Algeria and Morocco, where I still have most of my friends and relatives, on a regular basis. I have never been to the Middle East, but have been a part of the Middle Eastern community in California and the rest of the country, and have been declared an “honorary Palestinian” many times over by my Palestinian brothers and sisters out here. Besides the cartoons, I have done several sculptures honoring Palestine: See my web site, www.studiobendib.com, under “Public art”. My first statue was a tribute to Palestinian-American peace activist Alex Odeh, whom I knew in LA and who was murdered in Santa Ana by a member of the JDL in 1985; another one is the monument commemorating the Deir Yassin massacre of 1948.


PP: Have you tried other creative mediums besides cartoons, such as writing, poetry, etc?

Khalil: I do sculptures, ceramics, paintings, and also quite a bit of political comedy these days (“Prez in the Fez”: www.bendib.com/video)


PP: Do you have something to say about the backwardness and helplessness of the Arab world today and the corruption of the Arab rulers and their subservience to the US? What is your advice to the ordinary citizen living in those countries; what should he/she be doing to improve their condition?

Khalil: Yes, we Arabs suffer from a double-whammy: the corruption and shameless despotism of our own rulers back in the old country as well as the naked opportunistic imperialist aggression coming from outside our countries: France, Great Britain, Israel and now even the US. So we have a double mountain to climb, but I have great faith in our future generations of Arab and Muslim Americans to catch up and rectify these problems, inshaAllah.


PP: How about Arab and Muslim Americans; what is your hope and message to them? What should they be doing or not doing?

Khalil: As I was saying earlier, the hope comes from both the young Arab and Muslim Americans. I regularly get invited to do workshops and lectures for groups of youngsters across the country, and seeing how bright and strong in their identity our youth is in this country gives much hope and encouragement. I truly believe that, in a generation or so (20 to 30 years) our community will have accumulated so many brilliant lawyers, doctors, engineers, inventors, entrepreneurs, artists, actors and journalists (just like in the old days of Andalusia,) that it will become impossible to tread on our communities anymore, either here in America or back in Palestine and the rest of the Middle East. I believe that we’re about to gradually reach critical mass, just like other American ethnic communities before us, and Islamophobia and the victimization of Palestinians and other Arabs will soon become a thing of the past. So my message to our younger ones, is keep studying and working hard, don’t forget who you are, and soon we’ll show the world what we’re capable of!


PP: This is an unfair question, but can you identify two or three of your favorite cartoons?

Khalil: I can’t really pick between my children (cartoons or even among my cartoon books), but here are three that I consider among my classics.




(Please click on the cartoons to enlarge)

PP: Thanks Khalil for granting us this interview. We will always keep our eyes open to catch your next great cartoon and to post it here on Palestinian Pundit.

The One-State Solution

By MUAMMAR QADDAFI

THE shocking level of the last wave of Israeli-Palestinian violence, which ended with this weekend’s cease-fire, reminds us why a final resolution to the so-called Middle East crisis is so important. It is vital not just to break this cycle of destruction and injustice, but also to deny the religious extremists in the region who feed on the conflict an excuse to advance their own causes.

المخابرات المصرية تبتز جرحى غزة للإدلاء بمعلومات عن سلاح المقاومة


Egyptian Security Contractors for Zion!

هددتهم بوقف علاجهم "إن لم يعترفوا
!"

"القاهرة - المركز الفلسطيني للإعلام

قال جرحى فلسطينيون تلقوا العلاج في مستشفيات مصرية وعادوا إلى قطاع غزة إن قوى الأمن المصرية حققت مع بعضهم وطالبتهم بمعلومات عن أماكن تصنيع الصواريخ وكيفية تهريب الأسلحة إلى القطاع.

ونقلت موقع "الجزيرة نت" الإخباري على شبكة "الانترنت" عن الجرحى قولهم إن قوى الأمن المصرية حققت في المستشفيات مع عدد منهم بشكل عنيف، وهددت الرافضين للتحقيق بالملاحقة وعدم السماح لهم بإكمال العلاج في المستشفيات المصرية.

وأوضح المصابون أنهم بعد أن تماثلوا جزئياً للشفاء خضعوا للاستجواب من قوى الأمن المصرية الذين طلبوا منهم الإدلاء بمعلومات عن المقاومة، كما طالبوهم بعدم العودة لمساعدة حركة المقاومة الإسلامية "حماس".

وقال أحد الذين بقوا للعلاج في مصر باتصال هاتفي مع "الجزيرة نت" إن قوى الأمن طلبت منه إبلاغ المقاومة في غزة بأن القاهرة لن تسمح لهم بتهريب السلاح إلى غزة، ولن تسمح لحماس بإعادة بناء قدراتها من جديد.

وأوضح الجريح أنه فور تعافيه من الإصابة طلب منه الطبيب الانتظار في غرفة جانبية بالمستشفى، ومن ثم جاء إليه محققون من المخابرات المصرية وتعهدوا له ببقاء ما يدلي به من معلومات طي الكتمان.

وأضاف "سألوني عن المقاومة وكيف تخزن أسلحتها وكم يمكن أن تصمد فصائل المقاومة في غزة في وجه إسرائيل"، مشيراً إلى أنهم طلبوا منه معلومات عن حركة "حماس" وقياداتها "المختفية".

وقال أيضاً إنه في البداية كان التعامل معه "لطيفاً للغاية" لكنه حين أنكر معرفته بالمقاومة ضربه أحد المحققين على مكان الجرح، وقال له "لا تكذب أنت من حماس وكتائب القسام، ويجب أن تتحدث وإلا فلن نسمح لك بإكمال العلاج وسنرميك كالكلاب
". "

Out of the rubble


The war on Gaza has brought Palestinian politics to a breaking point. Mouin Rabbani wonders if a new national movement can emerge.

A Very Good Analysis and Recommended Reading
By Mouin Rabbani
The National

".......At a press conference the following day convened by Abu Ubaida, the spokesperson of the Martyr Izz al Din al Qassam Brigades, the Hamas military wing, the movement went one step further. “The Resistance”, Abu Ubaida intoned, “is the legitimate representative of the Palestinian people”.

What these statements make clear is that Hamas will no longer engage with Abbas, and is even less inclined to throw him a lifeline in the form of a national unity government he would appoint. These statements are not so much a direct challenge to his leadership as a confirmation that his legitimacy has been fatally damaged by the Gaza war. Even his hand-picked prime minister, Salam Fayyad, told journalists that the PA in Ramallah has been “marginalised”.

Israel’s war on the Gaza Strip has produced a transformational moment in Palestinian politics. It is a moment all too reminiscent of the period succeeding the 1967 War when the credibility of the prevailing Arab order collapsed and – deriving their legitimacy from the barrel of a gun – Yasser Arafat and a coalition of Palestinian guerrilla organisations seized control of the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO).......

..... The devastation in Gaza has made the inclination to challenge Israel and its occupation and the will to defy international pressure the central criteria for Palestinians. But Abbas will not be a party to this process: instead his ejection from the body politic has become its non-negotiable precondition. Because if there is one message it is “no more business as usual.” ......

....... It is a process that is certain to see the formal renunciation of the catastrophic Oslo agreements, and perhaps the abolition of the PA as well......

Key to this is Abbas’s relationship to his people: simply put, it never existed......

Abbas has by contrast been an inveterate elitist, who seems to have regarded the Palestinian population as an obstacle to be overcome so that the game of nations could proceed ......

Cursed with exceptional self-regard, Abbas has always shown disinterest in the opinions of others. From the moment he convinced himself of the sincerity of Bush’s visions, which put the onus on the Palestinians to prove they qualify for membership in the human race and are worthy of being spoken to by Tsipi Livni and Condoleezza Rice, there was no turning back. Henceforth the Palestinian security forces would point their weapons exclusively at their own people, and only Saeb Erakat would be aimed at Israel. At the United Nations, once a primary arena for the Palestinian struggle, Abbas’s emissary Riad Mansour was too busy drafting a resolution declaring Hamas a terrorist entity to deal with more trivial Palestinian concerns. It was simply impossible to steer Abbas towards a change of course, let alone a national dialogue that could produce a genuine strategy......

While many are arguing that Abbas is now paying the price for his passivity while Israel slaughtered Palestinians in Gaza, this is only one part of the story. At least as important is the manner in which he has conducted himself since December 27 – comprehensively out of touch with his own people, as if deliberately so, and dealing with the Gaza Strip as if it is a foreign country he has never heard of.

In his initial response Abbas laid responsibility for the conflict at Hamas’s doorstep, in one stroke reducing his role to that of a factional leader opportunistically siding with his cousin against his brother. More to the point, he unleashed the full power of his security forces against his own people. Not to prevent a Hamas coup in the West Bank, or even attacks against Israel, but to suppress pro-Palestinian demonstrations of the kind permitted even within Israel.......

There is no longer anything Abbas can say or do to remain in power. The only relevant question is if he will jump before he is pushed – with the coup de grace almost certain to come from within the Fatah movement or the ranks of the public rather than Islamist circles.

No less importantly, there is now also nothing his sponsors and allies can do to save his skin. Utterly cynical initiatives like that by the Europeans promising aid to a national unity government – which, when formed in 2007, served as a pretext for them to continue to boycott the PA – will achieve nothing. Bribes, threats, even wars or peace conferences can no longer prevent the emergence of a new Palestinian national movement. We do not yet know its shape, nor how it will emerge. At this point the only certainty is that unless it can more authentically represent the will and aspirations of its people – by challenging rather than accommodating the status quo – and thereby make more effective progress toward basic objectives, it will not last long."

Falk likens Gaza to Warsaw Ghetto


Press TV

"There is more than enough evidence that Israel committed war crimes in its three week-long offensive into Gaza, says a UN investigator.

UN special rapporteur Richard Falk called for an independent inquiry into Israel's violation of international humanitarian law. Falk said Israel's actions against the besieged Gazans are reminiscent of "the worst kind of international memories of the Warsaw Ghetto" which included the starvation and murder of Polish Jews by Nazi Germany in World War Two.

"There could have been temporary provision at least made for children, disabled, sick civilians to leave, even if where they left to was southern Israel," said the Jewish American academic on Thursday.

Falk, who was denied entry to Israel in December, said Gazans may have been mentally scarred for life because Israel made no effort to allow civilians to escape.

Israeli officials moved closer to being prosecuted for war crimes after Norwegian medics in Gaza found traces of depleted uranium on Gaza victims, suggesting that Israel used the illegal weapons in its war on the impoverished territory, which houses some 1.5 million Palestinians.

According to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), there is a "high risk of developing cancer from exposure to radiation emitted by ... depleted uranium weapons. This risk is assumed to be proportional to the dose received." The Geneva Convention has classified depleted uranium ammunitions as 'illegal weapons of mass destruction' due to their high radioactivity and toxicity.

Israel faces potential war crimes charges over its excessive use of other controversial weapons on the densely-populated coastal strip.......

Falk, dismissed Israel's argument that the assault was for self-defense, saying that "the UN charter, and international law, does not give Israel the legal foundation for claiming self-defense." "

Breaking Gaza's Will: Israel's Enduring Fantasy

By Ramzy Baroud
Palestine Chronicle

".....Olmert wants to "break the will" of Hamas, i.e. the Palestinians, since the Hamas government was elected and backed by the majority of the Palestinian people.

Isn't 60 years of suffering and survival enough to convince Olmert that the will of the Palestinians cannot be broken? How many heaps of wreckage and mutilated bodies will be enough to convince the prime minister that those who fight for their freedom will either be free or will die trying?

Far-right politician Avigdor Lieberman, a rising star in Israel, is not yet convinced. He thinks that more can be done to "secure" his country, which was established in 1948 on the ruins of destroyed Palestinian towns and villages. He has a plan. "We must continue to fight Hamas just like the United States did with the Japanese in World War II," said the head of ultra-nationalist opposition party Yisrael Beitenu.

A selective reader of history, Lieberman could only think of the 1945 atomic bombs dropped on Nagasaki and Hiroshima. But something else happened during those years that Lieberman carefully omitted. It's called the Holocaust, a term that many are increasingly using to describe the Israeli massacres in the Gaza Strip.

It is strange that conventional Israeli wisdom still dictates that "the Arabs understand only the language of force." If that were true, then they would have conceded their rights after the first massacre in 1948. But, following more than 60 years filled with massacres new and old, they continue to resist. "Freedom or death," is the popular Palestinian mantra. These are not simply words, but a rule by which Palestinians live and die. Gaza is the proof and Israeli leaders are yet to understand........"

Israel’s Lies

Henry Siegman
London Review of Books

".....Middle East peacemaking has been smothered in deceptive euphemisms, so let me state bluntly that each of these claims is a lie. Israel, not Hamas, violated the truce: Hamas undertook to stop firing rockets into Israel; in return, Israel was to ease its throttlehold on Gaza. In fact, during the truce, it tightened it further. This was confirmed not only by every neutral international observer and NGO on the scene but by Brigadier General (Res.) Shmuel Zakai, a former commander of the IDF’s Gaza Division.....

In other words, when Jews target and kill innocent civilians to advance their national struggle, they are patriots. When their adversaries do so, they are terrorists.....

Why then are Israel’s leaders so determined to destroy Hamas? Because they believe that its leadership, unlike that of Fatah, cannot be intimidated into accepting a peace accord that establishes a Palestinian ‘state’ made up of territorially disconnected entities over which Israel would be able to retain permanent control. Control of the West Bank has been the unwavering objective of Israel’s military, intelligence and political elites since the end of the Six-Day War.[*] They believe that Hamas would not permit such a cantonisation of Palestinian territory, no matter how long the occupation continues. They may be wrong about Abbas and his superannuated cohorts, but they are entirely right about Hamas.

Middle East observers wonder whether Israel’s assault on Hamas will succeed in destroying the organisation or expelling it from Gaza. This is an irrelevant question. If Israel plans to keep control over any future Palestinian entity, it will never find a Palestinian partner, and even if it succeeds in dismantling Hamas, the movement will in time be replaced by a far more radical Palestinian opposition......"

Al-Jazeera Video: Traders rebuild their tunnels in Gaza - 22 Jan 09



"Tunnels between Egypt and Gaza, which Israel say are used for weapons smuggling, was one of the main targets for Israel's air strikes.

Al Jazeera's Todd Baer reports from Rafah in Egypt, where many of the destroyed tunnels are now being rebuilt.

The Palestinians say the underground trading network is a necessary lifeline to get food, gas and medicine into the Strip since the border crossings remain closed."

Al-Jazeera Video: Assessing the aftermath in Gaza - 22 Jan 09



"Gaza has been shattered by Israel's devastating three week long war.

Amid the chaos and confusion, the people are showing their resilience yet again and are trying to repair their bombed out homes, schools and businessess in an effort to rebuild their lives.

Gaza remains beseiged and bereft of widespread international support.

Al Jazeera's Mike Hanna spoke to Gazans who feel let down by the international community. "

Video: Gaza villages Wiped off the map

You Have to See This Incredible Video
Contributed by asdf



"Another excellent report by Jonathan Miller. Telling the story of destruction and killing in Gaza."

Part II: Palestinian US College Grad Loses 2 Brothers in Israeli Shooting; Father Watched Son Bleed to Death After Israeli Troops Blocked Ambulances


Democracy Now!
With Amy Goodman

"We return to the heart-wrenching tale of Amer Shurrab, who lost two of his brothers on the same day in an Israeli attack in Gaza. Amer is a Palestinian from Khan Yunis living in the United States. He recently graduated from Middlebury College. On Friday, his father and two brothers were fleeing their village when their vehicle came under Israeli fire. Twenty-eight-year-old Kassab died in a hail of bullets trying to flee the vehicle. Eighteen-year-old Ibrahim survived the initial attack, but Israeli troops refused to allow an ambulance to reach them until twenty hours....."

Al-Jazeera Video: Israeli war conduct and outcome questioned - 21 Jan 09


"Israel's war on the Gaza Strip lasted three weeks and killed more than 1,300 people. Now there are more accusations about Israel's use of illegal weapons in the fighting. Just hours after Israeli forces withdrew from the Strip footage has also surfaced showing the tunnels that lead from Egypt into Gaza are still being used to smuggle in supplies. Destroying the tunnels was one of the principal justifications Israel gave for its offensive. Al Jazeera's Tarek Bazely reports."

Profound psychological damage in Gaza


Eva Bartlett writing from the occupied Gaza Strip, Live from Palestine, 21 January 2009

(Left) Graffiti left by Israeli soldiers in a house they occupied in Ezbet Abed Rabu, eastern Jabaliya.


"The streets leading from the seriously-damaged Wafa rehabilitation center in Shejaiyeh were filled with black filth smelling of sewage. The hospital -- attacked on 12 January with a chemical bomb that may well have been white phosphorus and which set fire to the roof, and whose four different buildings were shelled intensely on 15 January -- is trying to rebuild and reopen, as is the shelled, burned, seriously-damaged al-Quds hospital in the Tel al-Hawa neighborhood in Gaza City.

Even today, after mentioning to the Canadian TV crew accompanying me that fire blobs had burned up 'til yesterday, we found still more blobs spread out, smoldering and willingly breaking into white smoking fires anew. I have seen this often enough now. They were impressed by it, by the fact that it's now eight days after the fire and the blobs are still simmering, smoldering, ready to flame up....."

Alarm Spreads Over Use of Lethal New Weapons

By Erin Cunningham

"GAZA CITY, Jan 22 (IPS) - Eighteen-year-old Mona Al-Ashkar says she did not immediately know the first explosion at the United Nations (UN) school in Beit Lahiya had blown her left leg off. There was smoke, then chaos, then the pain and disbelief set in once she realised it was gone - completely severed by the weapon that hit her.

Mona is one of the many patients among the 5,500 injured that have international and Palestinian doctors baffled by the type of weaponry used in the Israeli operation. High-profile human rights organisations like Amnesty International are accusing Israel of war crimes.

Mona's doctors at Gaza City's Al-Shifa hospital found no shrapnel in her leg, and it looked as though it had been "sliced right off with a knife."

"We are not sure exactly what type of weapon can manage to do that immediately and so cleanly," said Dr. Sobhi Skaik, consultant surgeon general at Al-Shifa hospital. "What is happening is frightening. It's possible the Israeli army was using Gaza to experiment militarily."

Both international organisations and human rights groups, including the UN, Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, have condemned Israel's use of unconventional weapons in civilian areas of the Gaza Strip.

Amnesty International's chief researcher for Israel and the Palestinian Territories, Donatella Rovera, told IPS in Beit Lahiya that Israel's use of white phosphorus and other "area weapons" on civilian populations amounted to war crimes. "The kind of weapons used and the manner in which they were used indicates prima facie evidence of war crimes," she said......."

Captive Nation


How Gaza became a Palestinian prison

By Avi Shlaim

"....The brutality of Israel’s soldiers is matched by the mendacity of its spokesmen. Eight months before launching the war on Gaza, Israel established a National Information Directorate. Its core messages are that Hamas broke the ceasefire agreements; that Israel’s objective is the defense of its population; and that Israel’s forces are taking the utmost care not to hurt civilians. But it was not Hamas but the IDF that broke the ceasefire, with a raid into Gaza on Nov. 4 that killed six Hamas men. Israel’s objective is not just the defense of its population but the eventual overthrow of the Hamas government by turning the people against their rulers. And far from taking care to spare civilians, Israel is guilty of indiscriminate bombing and of a three-year blockade that has brought the inhabitants of Gaza to the brink of a humanitarian catastrophe.

No amount of military escalation can buy Israel immunity from rocket attacks from the military wing of Hamas. Despite all the death and destruction that Israel has inflicted on them, they kept up their resistance. This is a movement that glorifies victimhood and martyrdom. The only way for Israel to achieve security is not through shooting but through talks with Hamas, which has repeatedly declared its readiness to negotiate a long-term ceasefire with the Jewish state within its pre-1967 borders. Israel has rejected this offer for the same reason it spurned the Arab League peace plan of 2002: it involves concessions and compromises.

Israel’s record over the past four decades makes it difficult to resist the conclusion that it has become a rogue state with “an utterly unscrupulous set of leaders.” A rogue state habitually violates international law, possesses WMD, and practices terrorism—the use of violence against civilians for political purposes......"

Real News Video With Pepe Escobar: One nation under a groove

Pepe Escobar: What was Obama exactly saying in his acceptance speech?



"President Barack Obama's highly anticipated inauguration speech has been widely praised as serious and/or somber. Pepe Escobar argues that for all its soaring rhetoric, it was very short on specifics. It did not even mention China and Russia. It made a cursory acknowledgement of the Muslim world. It ignored the Americas - and native Americans. It did not renounce the war on terror framework. It certainly encouraged honesty, hard work and determination. But while claiming to set a new era of responsibility, Obama seemed to place most of this new responsibility over God's shoulders. Dr. Martin Luther King in his own time had been much more incisive."

In Israel, detachment from reality is now the norm

All these years on from Sabra and Chatila, has anything changed?

By Patrick Cockburn
The Independent

".....Soon after seeing Waltz with Bashir I saw TV pictures of the broken bodies of the Palestinians killed by Israeli bombs and shells in Gaza during the 22-day bombardment. At first I thought that little had changed since Sabra and Chatila. Once again there were the same tired and offensive excuses that Israel was somehow not to blame. Hamas was using civilians as human shields, and in any case – this argument produced more furtively – two-thirds of people in Gaza had voted for Hamas so they deserved whatever happened to them.

But on returning to Jerusalem 10 years after I was stationed here as The Independent's correspondent between 1995 and 1999 I find that Israel has changed significantly for the worse. There is far less dissent than there used to be and such dissent is more often treated as disloyalty.

Israeli society was always introverted but these days it reminds me more than ever of the Unionists in Northern Ireland in the late 1960s or the Lebanese Christians in the 1970s. Like Israel, both were communities with a highly developed siege mentality which led them always to see themselves as victims even when they were killing other people. There were no regrets or even knowledge of what they inflicted on others and therefore any retaliation by the other side appeared as unprovoked aggression inspired by unreasoning hate......."

So far, Obama's missed the point on Gaza...

By Robert Fisk

"It would have helped if Obama had the courage to talk about what everyone in the Middle East was talking about. No, it wasn't the US withdrawal from Iraq. They knew about that. They expected the beginning of the end of Guantanamo and the probable appointment of George Mitchell as a Middle East envoy was the least that was expected. Of course, Obama did refer to "slaughtered innocents", but these were not quite the "slaughtered innocents" the Arabs had in mind.

There was the phone call yesterday to Mahmoud Abbas. Maybe Obama thinks he's the leader of the Palestinians, but as every Arab knows, except perhaps Mr Abbas, he is the leader of a ghost government, a near-corpse only kept alive with the blood transfusion of international support and the "full partnership" Obama has apparently offered him, whatever "full" means. And it was no surprise to anyone that Obama also made the obligatory call to the Israelis.

But for the people of the Middle East, the absence of the word "Gaza" – indeed, the word "Israel" as well – was the dark shadow over Obama's inaugural address. Didn't he care? Was he frightened? Did Obama's young speech-writer not realise that talking about black rights – why a black man's father might not have been served in a restaurant 60 years ago – would concentrate Arab minds on the fate of a people who gained the vote only three years ago but were then punished because they voted for the wrong people? It wasn't a question of the elephant in the china shop. It was the sheer amount of corpses heaped up on the floor of the china shop......."

المصري: عباس سقط دستورياً ووطنياً وأخلاقياً والدعم الخارجي لن يمنحه الشرعية


أكد أنه "لا أحد يستطيع أن يسرق انتصار غزة من أهله"

"غزة - المركز الفلسطيني للإعلام
قللت حركة المقاومة الإسلامية "حماس" من أهمية ما أسماه محاولة ضخ الروح في جثة المفاوضات الفلسطينية ـ الصهيونية الهامدة، وأشار إلى أنها ليست إلا جزءا من محاولات دولية لصبغ الشرعية على محمود عباس الذي انتهت ولايته دستوريا.

ووصف عضو المجلس التشريعي الفلسطيني عن حركة المقاومة الإسلامية "حماس" مشير المصري في تصريحات صحفية المواقف الدولية المؤيدة لمحمود عباس بأنها "محاولة لسرقة انتصار غزة من أهله".

وقال: "لا أحد يستطيع أن يسرق انتصار غزة من أهله، ولا أحد يستطيع أن يحرف البوصلة بعد أن عجزت إسرائيل إحدى أكبر قوى العالم أمام الصمود الأسطوري للمقاومة،
والسيد محمود عباس ليس مؤهلا لأن يضاهي "حماس" التي تقود خيار الشعب الفلسطيني، لأن خياراته الاستسلامية العبثية لم تنتج شيئا، ومحاولة ضخ الروح في جثة المفاوضات الهامدة لن يكتب لها النجاح".

ورفض المصري اعتبار اتصال الرئيس الأمريكي باراك أوباما بمحمود عباس خطوة ذات مدلول سياسي كبير، وقال: "على صعيد الرئيس الأمريكي باراك أوباما فنحن سنحكم عليه من خلال سلوكه، وإن كنا نتمنى أن يخرج أمريكا بثوب جديد بعيدا عن السياسة التي خلفت الحروب وأن تقف الإدارة الأمريكية على الحياد في الصراع العربي ـ الإسرائيلي".

ونفى أن يكون لهذا الاتصال أي انعكاس سياسي لجهة منح عباس المنتهية ولايته الشرعية، وقال: "الشرعية السياسية لا تستمد من الخارج، فمحمود عباس سقط شرعياً ودستورياً فضلاً عن سقوطه الوطني والأخلاقي، وبالتالي هو لا يمثل الشعب الفلسطيني، وكل محاولات وضع أرجل خشب له كلها محاولات لا يمكن أن تمنحه أي شرعية وستوصله انحدار أكثر لدى الشعب الفلسطيني، والشرعية الوحيدة يمنحها الشعب، والحديث عن الثقة به في التسوية واشتراط الاعتراف بإسرائيل لحوار "حماس" اسطوانة مشروخة اعتدنا عليها من الغرب، وهي سياسة عرجاء لا يمكنها أن تحقق شيئا"، كما قال
. "

Audio (3 minutes) and Photos: 'Phosphorus shells' hit Gaza UN school

John Ging, head of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), describes the moments and aftermath of an Israeli strike on a UN school, designated as a shelter, in Beit Lahiya

The Guardian

Photographs by Mohammed Abed/AFP and agencies

A decisive loss for Israel


Hamas has emerged from the war stronger. Now we look to Obama to repair the errors of silence

Mousa Abu Marzook
(Deputy chief of the Hamas political bureau)
The Guardian, Thursday 22 January 2009

"Israel's objectives from the war on Gaza were set long before its launch: to remove the Hamas movement and government, achieve the reinstallation of the Fatah leader, Mahmoud Abbas, in Gaza, and end the armed resistance. Two other objectives were not announced. First, restore the Israeli public's wavering confidence in its armed forces after its defeat by Hezbollah in 2006. Second, boost the coalition government in the coming elections.

Accordingly, we declare that Israel lost, and lost decisively. What did it achieve? The killing of large numbers of civilians, children and women, and the destruction of homes, ministry buildings and other infrastructure with the most advanced US weapons and other internationally banned chemical and phosphorous elements. Almost 2,000 children were killed and injured in desperate pursuit of political goals. Many international organisations called these attacks war crimes, yet barely a word of denunciation was uttered by any western leader. What message does the EU mean to send Palestinians by its shameful silence on these crimes, when it speaks incessantly on human rights?

If anything, the last three weeks, and previous 18 months, have proved that the Palestinians can never be broken by either starvation, economic strangulation or brutal attack. European leaders have only one option: to recognise the outcome of a democratic process they had called for and supported.

The aggression failed to undermine or weaken the Hamas-led government, or turn Palestinians against Hamas. If anything, public support is stronger than ever in Palestine and worldwide. Hamas's military capabilities have not been hurt, either. This explains Israel scurrying to sign such a strange agreement with the US to stop arms reaching Hamas. It is doomed to fail. As the former Israeli chief of staff Moshe Ya'alon and Binyamin Netanyahu agreed, Israeli forces failed to achieve their objectives.

Why is Israel allowed a continuous flow of the most lethal arms, including banned weapons, while national resistance movements are denied the means of defence? International laws permit occupied nations to resist their occupiers, and that is a right we aim to utilise to the full.

Israel must accept the reality that it is incapable of breaking the Palestinian resistance. Similarly, Europe must accept that bringing back Abbas on an Israeli tank is not an option. Nor are attempts to win by "diplomacy" what the might of the Israeli military failed to secure by force. To state that all aid for Gaza reconstruction must go through the illegal government of Salam Fayyad suggests there is no end to some parties' exploitation of Palestinians. We will never cease to pursue national unity, but we will never allow it to be attained by compromising Palestinian rights.

And to President Obama we say: the wave of hope that met your election was heavily dampened by your silence on the Gaza massacre. This was compounded by your pre-election statement siding with the Israeli settlers of Sderot. You would do well to know the history of the places of which you speak. Sderot, which may be known to some as an Israeli town, lies on the ruins of Najd, a Palestinian village ransacked in May 1948 by Zionist terrorist gangs. Villagers were forced from their beds and homes with nothing but the clothes they were wearing, rendering them refugees for the next 61 years. That is the story of Sderot. It is never a good start to get your tyrant and victims mixed up, but there is still room for a revival of passionate optimism. Only if you decide to fairly address the issue of the 6 million Palestinian refugees and the ending of occupation of Palestinian lands, including Jerusalem, will you be able to start a new relationship with the Muslim world."

Israel Failed in Gaza Op; Arms Smuggling Never Stopped


Al-Manar

"22/01/2009 Although the Israeli air force bombed the Phildelphi corridor along the border thousands of times during the course of its aggression against the Gaza Strip, Israeli daily Haaretz quoted sources as saying that some tunnels running under the border between Egypt and the Strip have remained in use, and were in operation even during the fighting.

Contrary to Israeli official reports saying that Israeli army has achieved its war objectives in Gaza, Hamas was still able to smuggle arms, according to Haaretz report.

Israeli occupation government has announced that its goals in the 22-day offensive, to stop arms smuggling and enhance the “invincible army’s image” in the region after it was lost during the Second Lebanon War in 206, were achieved. However tunnels lined with wood reinforcement have been especially resistant to air force bombing raids.

According to residents of Rafah, the reinforced tunnels were even used during the Israeli military offensive to smuggle in a group of German doctors who wanted to provide medical care to Gaza residents. In addition to Palestinian smugglers, Bedouin from Sinai are also involved in the trade through the tunnels.

Since the implementation of the cease-fire, the Egyptians have opened their border with the Gaza Strip to shipments of medical personnel and supplies as well as a limited number of foreign journalists, but they then hindered the entry of additional representatives of the foreign press who have been waiting at the border.

The Israeli security establishment was not surprised by Wednesday's reports saying some smuggling tunnels under the Gaza Strip's border with Egypt have begun to operate again despite heavy bombing during the Israeli offensive. Israeli security officials said Hamas had tried to resume the smuggling while “Operation Cast Lead” was still ongoing, adding that they estimate the bombed tunnels will soon be reconstructed...... "

Wednesday, January 21, 2009


Casualties of the Bombing of Gaza.....
Too Bad They Are Not Under the Rubble.

Khaled Amayrah Arrested by P.A.


BY Professor Abdul Sattar Kasem Jan. 20/2009

"Palestinian Authority security arrested the Palestinian well known journalist and thinker, Khaled Al-Amayrah, for unknown reasons, but what is known is that Amayrah is an able journalist, he usually writes in English in many international information media, it is known that he is an observing Islamist, and professional journalist of high caliber, with high morals and deals with people with respect.

Amayrah is a strong defendant of Palestinian resistance in particular and Arab resistance as a whole, he opposes the recognition of Israel, condemns dealing with it and opposes the Arab security coordination with the Zionist entity as practiced by the Palestinian Authority. His writings had a great effect in explaining the Palestinian cause, and exposes the Zionist atrocities practiced against Palestinians in particular and the Arabs people in general.

It is a sign of the decaying of the Palestinian Authority in arresting Mr. Amayrah especially when the Palestinian Arab people are celebrating the steadfastness of Palestinian resistance in the face of the deadly Zionist military machine. This is as if the Palestinian authority rejects this great great military achievement on Palestinian soil for the first time on Palestinian Arab land against the savage occupier.

The Arab Palestinian people is at a historic stage after the war the Zionist enemy waged on the Gaza Strip, and we don’t believe that it wise to continue with the practices of the past."

Sayyed Nasrallah Congratulates Pal. Resistance on Victory


Al-Manar

"20/01/2009 Hezbollah Secretary General Sayyed Hasan Nasrallah congratulated the Palestinian Resistance movement Hamas on the victory it has achieved againt the Zionist brutal aggression in the Gaza Strip.

According to a statement released by Hamas, Sayyed Nasrallah praised, during a phone call he made with Hamas politburo head Khaled Meshaal, the Palestinian nation's sacrifices. His eminence noted that the Palestinians have showed in the Israeli deadliest offensive against the besieged strip high levels of pride, haughtiness, glory, disdain, steadfastness and firmness.

Sayyed Nasrallah emphasized that the Zionist entity has witnessed in Gaza its second defeat in less than two years and a half, recalling of the first defeat of the "invincible" army in July 2006 in Lebanon.

Hezbollah Secretary General, meanwhile, saluted the Palestinian Resistance heroes for their role in achieving the victory, pointing out that they lined up united in the battle of confrontation and fight.

For his part, Meshaal thanked Sayyed Nasrallah and Hezbollah in general for the stances they have taken during the Gaza operation, noting that the Lebanese group was always standing by the side of the Palestinian nation and its Resistance. "

Khalid Amayreh arrested by Abbas' "security" forces!!! Then released, UPDATE!!


Palestine Think Tank

"Confirmation from Khalid himself.

Dear friends, colleagues, brothers and sisters all over the globe.

I would like to thank each and everyone of you for your solidarity during my short but difficult ordeal. I am quite certain that had it not been for the public and media pressure on the PA, I would have been kept in that dark cell for many more weeks or months.

My brief incarceration was meant to make me exercise "self-censorship" and refrain from calling things by their real names. But, Nay, this I will never do.

Reingraved time after time
ever in its youthful prime,
my designs unchanged remain.

Khalid Amayreh

Aljazeera Television has just reported that journalist Khaled Al-Amayreh was arrested by Abbas's Preventive Security forces in Hebron two days ago. Visits to Amayreh in his prison cell have been denied.
PLEASE DISTRIBUTE THE NEWS OF THE ARREST OF THE PALESTINIAN JOURNALIST KHALID AMAYREH BASED IN THE OCCUPIED WEST BANK CITY OF KHALIL (HEBRON) BY THE PA SECURITY GOONS/CONTRAS. IT IS IMPORTANT TO GET THIS NEWS OUT....."

Israel's use of white phosphorus against Gaza civilians "clear and undeniable"


Amnesty International
19 January 2009

"Amnesty International delegates visiting the Gaza Strip found indisputable evidence of widespread use of white phosphorus in densely populated residential areas in Gaza City and in the north.

"Yesterday, we saw streets and alleyways littered with evidence of the use of white phosphorus, including still burning wedges and the remnants of the shells and canisters fired by the Israeli army," said Christopher Cobb-Smith, a weapons expert who is in Gaza as part of a four-person Amnesty International fact-finding team......"

Video: Tariq Ali | Stop the Gaza Massacre Rally in London | 8 January 2009



"...Held at Friends Meeting House London NW1

Speakers included
Tariq Ali
Tony Benn
George Galloway MP
Lindsey German (Stop the War)
Sasha Callaghan (UCU)
Hugh Lanning (PCS)
Jeremy Corbyn MP
Maryan (from Gaza)
Ismael Patel ( British Muslim Initiative)"

Depopulation, Destruction and Displacement of the Palestinian People

Al Nakba Redux

by Stephen Lendman
Global Research, January 21, 2009

"For Palestinians, the Nakba "Catastrophe" is their "Holocaust" six-month slaughter and displacement before and after the May 1948 establishment of Israel. In December 1947, Jews in Palestine numbered 600,000 compared to 1.3 million Palestinians. David Ben-Gurion ordered them removed and for "Every attack....to end with occupation, destruction and expulsion."

He meant depopulation, destruction, mass slaughter, displacement, and erasing a proud people's history. Palestine was to become Israel. Most of the job was completed, more in 1967, and thereafter incrementally until total dispossession is achieved. Gaza is the latest battleground. More ahead is planned. The struggle for liberation continues......

Looking Ahead

Editor Ali Abuninah of the Electronic Intifada reports that Israel's Gaza war failed to weaken Hamas and other resistance groups to clear the way for negotiating with its "chief Palestinian collaborator Mahmoud Abbas to manage Palestinians on (its) behalf until they (can) be forced out once and for all."

Regional dictators like Mubarak and the Saudi and Jordanian monarchies are on board "to demonstrate to their own people that resistance" is futile. "To win, Israel had to break Palestinian resistance. It failed....it galvanized and unified Palestinians like never before." Hamas and other resistance fought heroically for 23 days and stand ready to do it again.

"According to well-informed and credible sources, Israel did little harm to the modest but determined military capacity of the resistance. So Israel did what it does best: it massacred civilians" to get people to turn against their government. Instead, Palestinians and the Arab street are together against Israel.

"In popular esteem, Hamas and other Palestinian resistance factions (stand) alongside Hizbollah as effective bulwarks against Israeli and Western colonialism." Israel lost its legitimacy and can't win it by bombing and mass slaughter. It survives through violence, intimidation, and billions in US aid, but for how long.

Even the Wall Street Journal admits that Hamas gained support from the fighting. On January 20, correspondent Charles Levinson quoted Israeli Col. Shmuel Zakai saying that his country doesn't understand that winning hearts and minds is as important as battlefield victories. "We just keep creating bigger problems," he said. "Military power alone is not enough."

Palestinians remained steadfast through it all, and world public opinion now backs them and Hamas like never before. Yet their struggle for liberation persists - against America, the West, complicit Arab regimes, and racists like Israeli Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi Yona Metzger who wants Gazans dumped in a Palestinian state in the Sinai......."

Photostory: Israel attacks UN school in Gaza

Photostory, The Electronic Intifada, 20 January 2009

"On 17 January 2009, Israeli forces bombed a school run by the United Nations agency for Palestine refugees (UNRWA) in Beit Lahiya in the northern Gaza Strip. Around 1,600 Palestinians from the northern Gaza Strip, mostly families including young children, sought refuge at the school to escape Israeli air strikes that were targeting homes in densely populated areas. At least two children were killed in the attack and another dozen wounded by the white phosphorus bombs fired at the school.

The bombing was not an isolated incident of Israel targeting UN institutions and personnel since it launched a military siege against the Gaza Strip on 27 December 2008. At least 43 civilians were massacred on 6 January as they took shelter at the al-Fakhoura school in Jabaliya refugee camp. UN personnel have been shot and killed as they attempted to conduct relief operations in the Gaza Strip. Tons of desperately needed aid were destroyed on 15 January when Israeli forces shelled the UNRWA warehouse in Gaza City with what is suspected to be white phosphorous.

The below images were taken by UNRWA photographer Iyad El-Baba......."




Israel's right to defend itself

Joseph Massad, The Electronic Intifada, 20 January 2009
(Associate Professor of modern Arab politics and intellectual history at Columbia University in New York. He is the author of The Persistence of the Palestinian Question )

"The logic goes as follows: Israel has the right to occupy Palestinian land, lay siege to Palestinian populations in Bantustans surrounded by an apartheid wall, starve the population, cut them off from fuel and electricity, uproot their trees and crops, and launch periodic raids and targeted assassinations against them and their elected leadership, and if this population resists these massive Israeli attacks against their lives and the fabric of their society and Israel responds by slaughtering them en masse, Israel would simply be "defending" itself as it must and should......

....The problem is that the Palestinians, students of a universal humanism in which they consider themselves equal to everyone else, keep failing Israel's racial lessons and tests. What the Palestinians ultimately insist on is that Israel must be taught that it does not have the right to defend its racial supremacy and that the Palestinians have the right to defend their universal humanity against Israel's racist oppression. Will Israel and its allies ever learn that lesson? Israeli history tells us that as students of racial supremacy, Zionists have always failed the test of universal humanism."

Egypt Bent at the Border

By Adam Morrow and Khaled Moussa al-Omrani

"CAIRO, Jan 21 (IPS) - Tens of thousands of houses inside the Gaza Strip were destroyed by air strikes and artillery during Israel's recently concluded military campaign. Areas along Egypt's border with the hapless enclave, meanwhile, have not been immune from the devastation.

"Dozens of homes on the Egyptian side of the border were badly damaged as a result of nearby Israeli air strikes," Hatem Al-Bulk, journalist and political activist, told IPS. "Most people living within two kilometres of the frontier have left for safer locations."....."

U.N. Chief Appalled at Israeli Destruction in Gaza

By Thalif Deen

"UNITED NATIONS, Jan 20 (IPS) - When Israel went on a military rampage during its 22-day air strikes and artillery attacks on Gaza, it largely singled out residential neighbourhoods, hospitals, schools and U.N. buildings on the pretext of targeting Hamas fighters.

But John Ging, director of operations for the U.N. Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), based in Gaza, kept insisting there were no Hamas fighters anywhere in the vicinity of U.N.-run schools or warehouses.

"What we have regretted in the past is that we have not been given a hearing to answer," he told reporters Monday.

He charged that most of the allegations made by Israel were "unsubstantiated, unfounded - and continue to be repeated." ......."

Gaza and the Franco-Egyptian Proposal


By Dr. Elias Akleh
Palestine Chronicle

"The Israeli attack on Gaza had exposed the treacherous role the Egyptian Mubarak's regime had been playing, since he received presidency, in the Arab/Israeli conflict and in the Palestinian/Palestinian division. During the attack Mubarak's regime tried to portray itself as an honest mediator between Israel and Hamas, while, in reality, it was playing the role of an Israeli proxy negotiator, who was trying to impose Israeli conditions on Hamas government. The Israeli Foreign Minister, Tsibi Livni, had hinted to this when she stated that the negotiations through Egypt were not with Hamas but against it.

Few days before the Israeli onslaught on Gaza Tsibi Livni traveled to Egypt to coordinate with the Egyptian regime its role in the Israeli onslaught against Gaza. The Egyptian role was to keep Rafah Crossing closed against all fleeing Palestinians to safety in Egyptian territory, and against the flow of all kinds of aid into Gaza. Egyptian regime would, later, exonerate itself through an Egyptian/Israeli already-agreed upon ceasefire agreement.

The assumption was that the massive Israeli onslaught against Gaza would destroy Hamas government within a week, after which Palestinians would run to Egypt asking for mediation with Israel.....

Despite the collaboration of the Egyptian regime in choking and weakening Hamas government, and playing the Israeli proxy mediator role rather than supporting their Arab brothers against the Israeli genocide, Mubarak’s regime was abandoned and left exposed as a traitor, and was not given the chance to exonerate itself. Such is the fate of all so-called moderate Arab leaders. They are to be used and dumped when their usefulness expires. "

False Dawn

Obama's election doesn't mean peace is breaking out all over – far from it

By Justin Raimondo

".....This "regional" approach championed by Obama is a technocratic euphemism for yet more – and bigger – U.S. military interventions throughout the Middle East. The preparations for an Afghan "surge" have been long in the making, and in this arena Obama will take up where Bush left off, and then some......"

The myth of Israel's strategic genius

By Stephen M. Walt

".....These tactical achievements are part of a larger picture, however, and that picture is not a pretty one. Israel has also lost several wars in the past -- none of them decisively, of course -- and its ability to use force to achieve larger strategic objectives has declined significantly over time. This is why Israelis frequently speak of the need to restore their "deterrent"; they are aware that occasional tactical successes have not led to long-term improvements in their overall security situation. The assault on Gaza is merely the latest illustration of this worrisome tendency.

What does the record show?.....

The moral of this story is that there is no reason to think that Israel always has well-conceived strategies for dealing with the problems that it faces. In fact, Israel's strategic judgment seems to have declined steadily since the 1970s -- beginning with the 1982 invasion of Lebanon -- perhaps because unconditional U.S. support has helped insulate Israel from some of the costs of its actions and made it easier for Israel to indulge strategic illusions and ideological pipe-dreams. Given this reality, there is no reason for Israel's friends -- both Jewish and gentile -- to remain silent when it decides to pursue a foolish policy. And given that our "special relationship" with Israel means that the United States is invariably associated with Jerusalem's actions, Americans should not hesitate to raise their voices to criticize Israel when it is acting in ways that are not in the U.S. national interest.

Those who refuse to criticize Israel even when it acts foolishly surely think they are helping the Jewish state. They are wrong. In fact, they are false friends, because their silence, or worse, their cheerleading, merely encourages Israel to continue potentially disastrous courses of action. Israel could use some honest advice these days, and it would make eminently good sense if its closest ally were able to provide it. Ideally, this advice would come from the president, the secretary of state, and prominent members of Congress -- speaking as openly as some politicians in other democracies do. But that's unlikely to happen, because Israel's supporters make it almost impossible for Washington to do anything but reflexively back Israel's actions, whether they make sense or not. And they often do not these days."

Gaza's Sendoff to Bush
By Emad Hajjaj

Now we've all seen through the Israeli government's excuses

If the Hamas rockets are so lethal, why doesn't Israel swap an F-16 for some?

By Mark Steel
The Independent

"The worrying part about whether the ceasefire in Gaza can hold together will be whether the international community can stop the flow of arms to the terrorists. Because Israel's getting their planes and tanks and missiles from somewhere and until this supply is cut off there's every chance it could start up again.

The disregard for life from these terrorists and their supporters is shocking. For example Thomas Friedman, the New York Times columnist, wrote that the purpose of the Israeli attack must be to "inflict a heavy death toll and heavy pain on the Gaza population".

Replace "Gaza" with "western", and that could have been written by al-Qa'ida. Maybe this is the problem: the Israelis are writing their policies by downloading statements from an Islamic Jihad website and just changing the place names. Also, if the Israelis think the Hamas rockets are as lethal as they say, why don't they swap their F-16 fighters and Apachehelicopters for a few of them?....."

Israel wanted a humanitarian crisis

Targeting civilians was a deliberate part of this bid to humiliate Hamas and the Palestinians, and pulverise Gaza into chaos

Ben White
guardian.co.uk, Tuesday 20 January 2009

"The scale of Israel's attack on the Gaza Strip, and the almost daily reports of war crimes over the last three weeks, has drawn criticism from even longstanding friends and sympathisers. Despite the Israeli government's long-planned and comprehensive PR campaign, hundreds of dead children is a hard sell. As a former Israeli government press adviser put it, in a wonderful bit of unintentional irony, "When you have a Palestinian kid facing an Israeli tank, how do you explain that the tank is actually David and the kid is Goliath?".......

Yet, there is more going on here. Israel seeks to turn the Gaza Strip into a depoliticised humanitarian crisis, always on the brink of catastrophe, always dependent; its population reduced to ration-receiving clients of international aid. Yitzhak Rabin famously wished that Gaza "would just sink into the sea", but perhaps the best Israel can do is to share the problem with the international community, possibly to the extent of troops on the ground.

Increasingly focusing on Egyptian responsibility is also part of this, whether in terms of arms smuggling, aid supplies, or for some, direct rule.

In all of this, the Gaza Strip has become a laboratory for future possible scenarios in the West Bank (where a process of "development-isation" and NGO-funded occupation is well established). All three of these Israeli aims – to delegitimise and sideline Hamas, to persuade Palestinians to give up their resistance and to shirk responsibility for a shattered Gaza Strip – require the deliberate commission of war crimes and gross human rights abuses. As time will tell, they are also doomed to fail."

UN chief demands investigation into Israeli attack on Gaza headquarters, with Video


• Ban Ki-Moon visibly angry at sight of burned-out buildings

Peter Beaumont in Jerusalem and Owen Bowcott
guardian.co.uk, Tuesday 20 January 2009

" The secretary general of the United Nations has called for a full investigation into Israel's shelling of three of its buildings in the Gaza Strip during its three-week long assault against Hamas. A visibly furious Ban Ki-moon condemned as "outrageous, shocking and alarming" the destruction he had seen while touring Gaza.....

....."These are heartbreaking scenes I have seen and I am deeply grieved by what I have seen today," he said, standing against a backdrop of still-smoking food aid in a UN warehouse destroyed by Israeli gunfire last Thursday.

Demanding a proper judicial inquiry and guarantees that UN buildings would not be attacked again, Ban said: "I am just appalled. I am not able to describe how I am feeling, having seen this site of the bombing of the United Nations compound. This was an outrageous and totally unacceptable attack against the United Nations."..... "

'لعنة غزة' ستطارد الكثيرين

'لعنة غزة' ستطارد الكثيرين

عبد الباري عطوان

".....
كان من المفترض ان يتنبه الزعماء العرب الذين تداعوا لهذه القمة، الى هذه اللحظة التاريخية، وان يظهروا بمظهر القوي، الحريص على قضاياه، وتعزيز رغبته في اثبات وجوده على الساحة الدولية، ولعب دور فاعل في تكريس استقرارها، والانتصار لقضاياه المصيرية، ولكن هذا لم يحدث مطلقا، فقد ظهر هؤلاء الزعماء امام مواطنيهم الغاضبين من عجزهم، وتبلّد مشاعرهم، وافتقادهم زمام المبادرة، مفلسين كليا، على الصعد كافة، السياسية منها على وجه الخصوص. ونحن هنا لا نتحدث عن الافلاس العسكري، لانه مسألة ميؤوس منها، ويتساوى في ذلك محورا الاعتدال والممانعة.
ملحمة الصمود في غزة لم تستحق من هؤلاء الزعماء غير كلمات عابرة، تفتقر الى الحرارة، وتركز على المال تحت عنوان 'اعادة الاعمار'، ولم ترد كلمة المقاومة اطلاقا في البيان الختامي، ولو بشكل عابر، بينما تم التأكيد على شرعية سلطة بلا شرعية دستورية او اخلاقية، بعد سقوطها المريع طوال فترة المجازر، وتبرئتها للجلاد، ولومها للضحية، كأن المقاومة اصبحت عارا، خاصة اذا مارسها من هم تحت الاحتلال.
.....
السيد عمرو موسى بشرنا قبيل انعقاد قمة الكويت، بأنه سيعرض على الزعماء في القمة مجموعة من الخيارات البديلة لمبادرة السلام العربية، ولكن في الجلسات المغلقة، وبعد اختتام القمة قال إنه سيتولى شخصيا البحث عن هذه الخيارات والبدائل. اي تهريج هذا، فأصغر طفل عربي يعرف ان بديل فشل المساعي السلمية هو وضع استراتيجية لاستخدام كل اسلحة المواجهة المتاحة من سياسية واقتصادية وعسكرية. وهناك الكثير منها في حوزة النظام العربي، ولا يتطلب الامر اجراء بحث عنها
.....
شعرت بالخجل الشديد وانا ارى بان كي مون امين عام الامم المتحدة يقف على انقاض مقر المنظمة الدولية المهدم، ويدين هذا العدوان بأقوى الكلمات، ويتعهد بعقاب ومطاردة كل الذين اقدموا على ارتكاب جرائم قتل الاطفال وتدمير منازلهم فوق رؤوس اهلهم. فقد كنت اتمنى لو ان السيد احمد ابو الغيط، او الرئيس مبارك نفسه، او ايا من قادة محور الاعتدال، وبالذات من حلفاء واشنطن الحميمين فعل ذلك.

امين عام الامم المتحدة الكوري البوذي كان اكثر تعاطفا مع معاناة اهالي قطاع غزة من معظم المشاركين في قمة الكويت، بل ومن 'الرئيس' الفلسطيني محمود عباس نفسه، فلم يوجه كلمة لوم واحدة الى المقاومة، واتهم اسرائيل بارتكاب جرائم حرب والاستخدام المفرط للقوة، ووعد بعدم التخلي عن المشردين وذوي الضحايا، وتقديم تقارير وافية عن كل ما شاهده من مآس الى اعضاء المنظمة الدولية ومؤسساتها.
أسعدني اكثر مشاهدة جون جانغ ممثل الاونروا في القطاع الذي كان الناطق باسم الضحايا ومأساتهم في القطاع، يتحرك وسط انقاض القصف طوال الاسابيع الثلاثة من عمر العدوان، معرضا حياته للخطر، وفاضحا مرتكبي المجازر على شاشات الفضائيات، ومتحدثا الى الغرب المنافق المتواطئ بلغته، وبطريقة مؤثرة. ان هذا الرجل يستحق كل التكريم ليس من النظام العربي الفاسد، وانما من منظمات حقوق الانسان، بل يستحق جائزة نوبل نفسها.
المعركة الدائرة حاليا ليست حول كيفية حماية قطاع غزة من عدوان متوقع، وانما كيفية ارسال الاموال المرصودة لاعادة الاعمار.
اموال اعادة الاعمار يجب ان تذهب للحكومة المنتخبة والشرعية، الحكومة التي قاومت وصمدت وقدمت الشهداء والضحايا، لتكون تحت اشرافها، واذا تعذر ذلك فلتوضع تحت تصرف منظمات دولية مثل وكالة غوث وتشغيل اللاجئين الاونروا، ففيها من الرجال والنساء من امثال جون جانغ، والسيدة كارين ابو زيد من هم محل ثقة وتقدير، بعد ان اثبتوا ذلك عمليا في اللحظات الخطرة.

الصمود البطولي لأهل قطاع غزة احدث حالة 'فرز' تاريخية في المنطقة العربية، فرز بين الانظمة والشعوب الحية، فرز بين من يقفون في خندق المقاومة ومن يقفون في خندق استجداء السلام والاستسلام، فرز بين الاعلام الشريف القابض على جمر الكرامة، واعلام التزوير والتعتيم وتوفير المنابر للمتواطئين مع العدوان ومجازره.
'لعنة غزة' ستظل تطارد الكثيرين، خاصة اصحاب الفخامة والجلالة والسمو الذين رفضوا حتى تجميد مبادرة سلام ماتت وتعفنت على مدى سبع سنوات من الاستجداء، دون ان يلتفت اليها احد."

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Israel's Doctrine of Destruction

Bombs Meant to "Send Gaza Back Decades"

By JONATHAN COOK
CounterPunch

"In the last days before Israel imposed a unilateral ceasefire in Gaza to avoid embarrassing the incoming Obama administration, it upped its assault, driving troops deeper into Gaza City, intensifying its artillery bombardment and creating thousands more displaced people.

Israel’s military strategy in Gaza, even in what its officials were calling the “final act”, followed a blueprint laid down during the Lebanon war more than two years ago.......

And international donors are already reported to be tired of funding building projects in Gaza only to see them destroyed by Israel a short time later.

With more than a hint of exasperation, Norway’s foreign minister, Jonas Gahr Stoere, summed up the general view of donors last week: “Shall we give once more for the construction of something which is being destroyed, re-constructed and destroyed?”"

Current Al-Jazeera (Arabic) Online Poll


The question is:

Who Should receive Gaza Reconstruction funds, the Ramallah PA or the Hamas government in Gaza?

With over 4,000 responding so far, 93% said the Hamas government in Gaza.