Tuesday, January 9, 2018

US hypocrisy, from Cairo to Tehran

Washington would be better off challenging absolute theocracies and brutal dictatorships, rather than confronting a semi-democracy in a region in which tyranny and absolutism are the norm

Soumaya Ghannoushi

Link

Last week protests broke out in the city of Isfahan, spreading to Iran's remaining cities, including the capital, Tehran.
The riots have given voice to calls for socio-economic change amid rising deprivation and unemployment among young people and a sense of injustice among poorer Iranians. These groups have suffered the brunt of inefficient economic management and the effects of the embargo imposed by international forces on Iran for many years.
The protests have revealed the vast gap between educated Iranian youth and successive Iranian governments, both conservative and reformist.
This latest wave of protests in Iran will most likely be resolved sooner or later, but will force the authorities to pay more attention to the pulse of the Iranian street

A fully fledged revolution?

Three actors have responded to this political crisis at lightning speed, each with its own stakes and calculations, in an attempt to turn this relatively limited social mobilisation into a fully fledged revolution against the government.
First are the Gulf states, which have fiercely pushed back against the Arab Spring, using money and the media to crush the uprisings, going so far as to engineer a military coup in Egypt in 2013. 
Ironically, these states are dubbing the riots the "Persian Spring". In other words, what is forbidden for the Arabs is permissible, even desirable, for Iranians.
The second is Israel, which, from the first months of political transformations that swept across the region in 2011, had labelled them "the Arab winter", seeing them as an existential threat and a danger to its efforts to promote itself as the sole democracy in a Middle Eastern sea of ​​dictatorships.
The third is the Trump administration, which had in the past shown no interest in democratic change in the region, instead devoting its energy to annulling the nuclear agreement with Iran and repositioning itself in the Middle East after successive US withdrawals since its defeat in Iraq. 
Its UN representative had rushed to put the Iranian protests on the agenda of the Security Council, an institution which only a few days ago was denounced by her, accusing it of being hostile to Israel and threatening to suspend its funding. 

Nauseating hypocrisy

The mobilisation of Iranian youth has no doubt many reasons, given the rise in marginalisation, unemployment, poverty rates and living costs. The main driving force behind this wave seems to be poor and marginalised social sectors, which did not put forward any clear political demands. 
Unlike the protests that had erupted in 2009 and were spearheaded by the reformists, this latest movement doesn't appear to be led by any specific political group.
Despite reservations about the Iranian system, it is more democratic than those of Washington’s Arab allies in the region (Reuters)
The rhetoric adopted by the US and its allies lacks any credibility, for the simple reason that this administration is the least qualified to promote democracy and human rights in the region, given its extensive financial transactions and involvement in arms and oil deals in the Middle East (as demonstrated by Trump's recent visit to Saudi Arabia, from which he returned laden with contracts and gifts).
Sooner or later, the Iranian government will be forced to allow greater openness towards a more liberal Islamic approach. Perhaps the current protests will take the country further in this direction
More importantly, only a few hundred miles from Iran, a bloody military coup had trampled over the people's will, imposed absolute rule, placed an elected president behind bars, and subjected him to a slow death policy, while America and the West look on silently, even approvingly.
This nauseating hypocrisy - supporting our dictator friends, aiding and abetting them while they trample upon our much-vaunted values of human rights and democracy, while using these hollow principles as whips with which to flagellate our adversaries - has become plain for all to see in the Middle East and beyond. 
Evidently, the political situation in Iran is far from ideal and the government still imposes many political and social restrictions on Iranian society. 

The pulse of the street

Yet the situation is undeniably superior to that reigning in much of the region, dominated either by military rulers unconstrained by a constitution, parliament or political institutions (as is the case in Egypt, Syria, Eastern Libya, Sudan and others), or by monarchs, who enjoy absolute power and wealth, dictating the fate of their people from the cradle to the grave in the name of divine authority or a "natural right to rule" passed down from father to son.
The truth is that whatever our reservations with the Iranian system, it is more democratic than those of Washington's Arab allies in the region.
Washington would be better off challenging absolute theocracies and brutal dictatorships, rather than confronting a semi-democracy in a region in which tyranny and absolutism are the norm. 
This means introducing constitutions that respect universal standards, halting incidents of arbitrary detention and torture, and introducing free elections – at least at municipal council level, before we can even begin to talk about elected parliaments or governments, a fantasy under governments that hold the destinies of their nations in their iron grip and see any criticism of rulers as an act of treachery punishable by death.

Democracy and theocracy

This latest wave of protests in Iran will most likely be resolved sooner or later, but will force the authorities to pay more attention to the pulse of the Iranian street. This will force the Islamic Republic to allow more political openness and lift restrictions on public and private freedoms, given that it its political legitimacy is derived from a popular revolution.
Since Mohammad Khatami's term, reformists have made significant strides towards greater political and cultural openness, despite the pressures imposed by a harsh US blockade and extensive record of Iranian interventions in the region, from Iraq to Syria, Yemen, Lebanon and elsewhere.
READ MORE►
The Islamic revolution that overthrew the shah's rule in 1979 established a government that combines both democracy and theocracy. 
Sooner or later, the Iranian government will be forced to allow greater openness towards a more liberal Islamic approach. Perhaps the current protests will take the country further in this direction.
The most urgent task for the Americans, if they are serious about calling for freedom, is to impose a minimal level of democracy on their allies in the region, from bloodthirsty generals to authoritarian kings and emirs.

- Soumaya Ghannoushi is a British-Tunisian writer and expert in Middle East politics. Follow her on Twitter: @SMGhannoushi

Trump Named The World’s No. 1 Oppressor Of Press Freedom

A journalism group named the president among repressive leaders who “have gone out of their way to attack the press” and undermine free speech.





President Donald Trump, who recently said he would announce the “MOST DISHONEST & CORRUPT MEDIA AWARDS OF THE YEAR,” has been awarded the title of the world’s most oppressive leader toward press freedom by the Committee to Protect Journalists.
Trump claimed the journalism organization’s top prize for “overall achievement in undermining global press freedom,” and joins four other leaders, including strongmen like Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Russian leader Vladimir Putin, who “have gone above and beyond to silence critical voices and weaken democracy,” the Committee to Protect Journalists said Monday.
The group said its awards were for “recognizing world leaders who have gone out of their way to attack the press and undermine the norms that support freedom of the media.” Though CPJ determined that countries like Russia and China hold the tightest grip on their national media, it declared Trump the winner for “overall achievement.”
Trump’s disrespect for the First Amendment is his most obvious offense, CPJ noted, and is so flagrant that leaders in other countries have adopted his “fake news” term for unflattering coverage.

I will be announcing THE MOST DISHONEST & CORRUPT MEDIA AWARDS OF THE YEAR on Monday at 5:00 o’clock. Subjects will cover Dishonesty & Bad Reporting in various categories from the Fake News Media. Stay tuned!
In addition, “under Trump’s administration, the Department of Justice has failed to commit to guidelines intended to protect journalists’ sources, and the State Department has proposed to cut funding for international organizations that help buttress international norms in support of free expression,” CPJ said. “As Trump and other Western powers fail to pressure the world’s most repressive leaders into improving the climate for press freedom, the number of journalists in prison globally is at a record high.”
Trump was named runner-up in CPJ’s “Most Thin-Skinned” category, losing to Erdoğan. Trump’s attacks on the media are vicious and frequent, and he has responded to criticism by threatening lawsuits and the removal of broadcast licenses.
“CPJ research shows that when public figures and political leaders lob insults at the media, they encourage self-censorship and expose journalists to unnecessary risk,” the organization said.
Trump’s latest media attacks have focused on journalist Michael Wolff, whose new book Fire and Fury has sent the president and his administration into a tailspin. Though Trump has frequently denigrated CNN, he had adviser Stephen Miller appear on the network’s “State of the Union” broadcast Sunday in an attempt to defend Trump in the face of the book. 
Miller was escorted off set after host Jake Tapper cut short the disastrous interview. “I think I have wasted enough of my viewers’ time,” Tapper told Miller. Trump, meanwhile, contended that Tapper “got destroyed” in the interview. 
Trump tweeted that he will present his supposed media awards, which he renamed the “Fake News Awards,” on Jan. 17.

موقع إيلاف السعودي يجري مقابلة مع زعيم المعارضة الإسرائيلية



كبير

أجرى موقع "إيلاف" السعودي مقابلة مع رئيس حزب العمل الإسرائيلي وزعيم المعارضة إسحق هرتسوغ وصف خلالها وليَّ العهد السعودي محمد بن سلمان بأنه أحد الثوريين الكبار في الشرق الأوسط، وقال إنه يحترم كثيرا الخطوات التي يقوم بها.
وهذه هي المقابلة الثانية من نوعها مع شخصية رسمية إسرائيلية يجريها الموقع السعودي، إذ سبق أن أجرى مقابلة مماثلة في نوفمبر/تشرين الثاني الماضي مع رئيس الأركان الإسرائيلي الجنرال غادي إيزنكوت.
وخلال المقابلة، وجّه هرتسوغ -وهو أيضا زعيم كتلة المعارضة داخل الكنيست- دعوة إلى العرب -وفي مقدمتهمالسعودية- للعمل على الخروج مما وصفه بالطريق المسدود في عملية السلام.
ورأى هرتسوغ أن هناك دوراً كبيراً في هذه المرحلة للمملكة العربية السعودية التي قال إنه يجب مساعدتها في إحياء العملية السلمية مع الفلسطينيين.
وقال إن السعودية والإمارات والرئيس المصري عبد الفتاح السيسي وملك الأردن عبد الله الثاني حاولوا مراراً حمل الفلسطينيين على العودة إلى المفاوضات، مشيرا إلى أن السيسي وابن سلمان وولي عهد أبو ظبي محمد بن زايديقدمون طروحات مثيرة للإعجاب.
وطالب هرتسوغ خلال المقابلة مع "إيلاف" بمنح السعودية دوراً مركزياً في الإشراف على الأماكن المقدسة في فلسطين، بالنظر إلى تجربتها في إدارة الأماكن المقدسة في مكة والمدينة.
وأكد أن حزب العمل وحلفاءه سيسقطون حكومة رئيس الوزراء بنيامين نتنياهو اليمينية، وسيفاوضون الفلسطينيين على حل الدولتين.

Al-Jazeera Cartoon: السلاح العربي

كاريكاتير: السلاح العربي

Emad Hajjaj's Cartoon: المخابرات والاعلام !

المخابرات والاعلام !

Monday, January 8, 2018

Actress, presenter, MP, spy: Egypt's covert operatives pushing Trump Jerusalem move

Four influential Egyptians were allegedly tapped up to back US recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital. MEE looks at their profiles

Link

Four Egyptian television and film personalities have allegedly been directed by Egypt's secret service to publicly back Donald Trump's decision to recognise Jerusalem as Israel's capital.
In four phone conversations, a man named by the New York Times as Captain Ashraf al-Kholi told Mofid Fawzy, Saeed Hassaseen, Yousra and Azmi Megahed that while the Egyptian state would condemn the move, it wanted highly influential people like them to help convince Egyptians the plan was in their country's interests.
Middle East Eye looks at the four alleged agents of the Egyptian state.

ACTRESS: YOUSRA


One of the biggest Egyptian actresses, known both regionally and internationally. She describes herself as a "Nasserist" and is known to support the Egyptian state.
The 66-year-old's first acting breaks were in the 70s and Yousra, real name Civene Nessim, has appeared in nearly 60 feature films and more than a dozen serials.
Working with well-known Egyptian actor Adel Emam on three films, al-Mansi (The Forgotten), Al Irhab Wal Kabab (Terrorism and Kebab), and Toyour al-Zalam (Birds of Darkness), all three movies used comedy to deliver an underlying political message to great critical and public acclaim.
Youssra has received over 50 awards in recognition of her work as a UN Development Programme goodwill ambassador.
She demonstrated against Israeli involvement in the Lebanese civil war, and demanded the Israeli ambassador be expelled from Egypt.
Yousra told the Egyptian news website Masrawy she had never heard of Ashraf al-Kholi: "This is impossible. The report is not true."

PRESENTER: MOFID 'MOUSTAFEED' FAWZY 

A TV presenter and journalist of many years, known for his flamboyant dress sense and hairstyle.
He has hosted the programme Talk of the Town, broadcast on state television, for nearly three decades and was also a co-host for Al-Qahira Al-Youm.
After a seven-year hiatus following the 2011 Egyptian revolution, Fawzy is due to return to TV, joining the privately owned pro-government CBC channel.
Fawzy also writes for the pro-government Egyptian newspapers al-Masry Youm and al-Watan. 
Both al-Watan and CBC Channel are owned by Egyptian businessman Mohamed al-Amin.
He is nicknamed "Moustafeed" (or "beneficiary") for appearing to always side and promote government opinions. 
The New York Times said Fawzy quickly denied taking part in any such conversation and immediately hung up the phone when contacted.

PRESENTER: AZMI MEGAHED

A former army brigadier who became a sports presenter and talk show host in 2016.
He currently presents the al-Malaaf programme on the al-Aseema channel.
The Times said Megahed confirmed his conversation with the secret services officer and agreed to his request based on his personal assessment of the need to avoid a fresh outbreak of violence.
"I am friends with Ashraf and we talk all the time,” he told the newspaper. “Another intifada would be bad. I have no problem saying all of the things you have heard in that call in public.
"We should have buses pick up all the people who say they want to go fight for Jerusalem and actually drive them to Jerusalem.
"Go fight if you are so tough. People are sick of the slogans and all that. I only care about the interests of my country."
On television, after the conversation with the spy, he told his audience of the issue of Jerusalem: "Enough already. It got old."

MP: SAEED HASSASEEN

Elected two years ago as an independent candidate, Hassaseen is a member of the Egyptian parliament and a supporter of the Sisi government. 
He is also the former owner of the television channel al-Aseema, which he sold to the Egyptian intelligence services a month ago.
The New York Times reported Hassaseen as telling the secret services officer: “Give me orders, sir. I am at your command.”
Hassaseen said he would sue the New York Times for its article, telling al-Balad: “No intelligence officer has contacted me... and no one dictates my opinions to me."

SPY: ASHRAF AL-KHOLI


The government interlocutor, according to the New York Times.
Described as a captain in the secret intelligence services, nothing is known of Kholi save for his dedication to the Egyptian state.
“The point that is dangerous for us is the intifada issue,” Captain Kholi said in one of the conversations. “An intifada would not serve Egypt’s national security interests because an intifada would revive the Islamists and Hamas. Hamas would be reborn once more.”
“At the end of the day, later on, Jerusalem won’t be much different from Ramallah. What matters is ending the suffering of the Palestinian people.
"Concessions are a must, and if we reach a concession whereby Ramallah will be the capital of Palestine, to end the war, then we would go for it.”

التسجيلات الصوتية المسربة لصحيفة نيويورك تايمز

A GREAT CARTOON BY EMAD HAJJAJ

القدس لمن ؟!

Sunday, January 7, 2018

ماذا ستجني المخابرات المصرية من ضم القدس لإسرائيل؟

رأي القدس


Link

كشفت صحيفة «نيويورك تايمز» الأمريكية تسريبات تتضمن مكالمات لأحد ضباط المخابرات المصرية لثلاثة إعلاميين من مقدمي البرامج الشعبية على الفضائيات (إضافة إلى الفنانة يسرا) توجههم للعمل على إقناع المشاهدين بعدم مهاجمة قرار الرئيس الأمريكي دونالد ترامب حول القدس والترويج لفكرة أن يكتفي الفلسطينيون برام الله عاصمة لهم بدلا من المدينة المقدسة.
حسب أحد التسجيلات التي انكشفت يتوجه ضابط الأمن المصري، المدعو أشرف الخولي، إلى المذيع التلفزيوني عزمي مجاهد بالسؤال: «ما هو الفرق بين القدس ورام الله؟» وهو أمر يوافقه عليه المذيع ثم يسوّقه في برنامجه، وفي اتصال آخر يقول الخولي لمقدم البرامج سعيد حساسين: «اتصلت بك فقط كي أقول لك ما هو موقف أجهزة الأمن المصرية» ويشرح له «الفائدة التي يمكن أن نحققها من إعلان القدس عاصمة لإسرائيل».
يعتبر ضابط الأمن في التسريبات أن موقف النظام المصري مشابه لمواقف الأنظمة العربية في الإدانة اللفظية لقرار ترامب لكنه «بعد كل شيء سيصبح حقيقة واقعة» لأن الفلسطينيين، حسب رأيه، «لا يستطيعون الاعتراض» ولأن النظام المصري «لا يريد بدء حرب. لدينا ما يكفي من المشاكل»، إضافة لذلك، يقول الضابط إن «أجهزة المخابرات خائفة من الانتفاضة لأنها لن تخدم المصالح الوطنية لمصر لأنها ستعزز نفوذ الإسلاميين وحماس».
ربّما لا تكشف هذه التسريبات عن مفاجأة حقيقية للنخب السياسية العربية حول موقف النظام المصري المخزي من المسألة الفلسطينية والقدس لكنّ استهداف المخابرات المصرية للإعلام يعني أنها تراهن على تضليل مواطنيها لمعرفتها بالرمزية الإسلامية الهائلة للقدس في ضمير شعبها، والكره الطبيعي لإسرائيل لدى المصريين.
غير أن لكشف التسجيلات، ربّما، هدفا آخر أيضاً، فإذا كانت التوجيهات الأمنية تستهدف تشويش بوصلة بسطاء المصريين، فإن فضح الأمر قد يكون أحد طرق إدارة الرئيس عبد الفتاح السيسي في إيصال رسالة اعتذارية عن موقف حكومة مصر المعلن، وتضامنها في مجلس الأمن والجمعية العامة للأمم المتحدة مع قضية القدس، إلى سيد البيت الأبيض وذلك بعد أن هدّد بوقف المساعدات المالية للسلطة الفلسطينية، وأوقف المعونة العسكرية لباكستان (وهي في حال شبيهة بمصر).
تستحقّ الأفكار التي وردت في التسريبات، رغم ذلك، بعض التحليل، فهي في النتيجة، قد تكون قريبة جدّاً من طريقة تفكير السيسي نفسه وبطانته العسكرية والأمنية.
المطابقة بين الولايات المتحدة الأمريكية ورئيسها (الذي يعاني من طعون كبيرة في أهليته العقلية والسياسية)، هي أحد أفكار التسريبات، وهي فكرة قد تكون مستمدة من مطابقة زعماء الدول العربية لأنفسهم مع بلدانهم، وهذه مسألة ذات حدّين، فمراهنة بعض القادة العرب، كالسيسي ومحمد بن سلمان، على معادلة ترامب = أمريكا قد تفيد على المدى القصير، لكنّ التهوّر الذي نراه في استخدامها، قد يثبت أنه أكثر ضررا مما يعتقد ضباط الأمن ورؤساؤهم.
مفهوم طبعاً أن النظام المصري «لا يريد حرباً» ولكنّ التناقض يقع حين يقول الخولي إن «الفلسطينيين لا يستطيعون الاعتراض» ثم يقول إن «أجهزة الأمن خائفة من الانتفاضة»، فإذا كان الفلسطينيون لا يستطيعون الاعتراض فعلاً فلماذا تخاف أجهزة الأمن المصرية من انتفاضة فلسطينية؟
غير أن قمة الركاكة تكمن في القول إن النظام المصري سيستفيد من إعلان القدس عاصمة لإسرائيل، أما كيف ستستفيد مصر من انتزاع المدينة المقدسة لكل المسلمين في العالم وضمها لإسرائيل وخنق آمال الفلسطينيين بدولة مستقلة وحصارهم وانتزاع هويتهم وتأجيج الطابع الديني للصراع مع إسرائيل فهذه مسألة لا يستطيع غير «ضابط أمن رفيع» أن يجيب عليها.

الحصاد-مصر.. ما وراء صفقة القرن



EXCELLENT....EXCELLENT!!

تسريبات تكشف المستور حول القدس وصفقة القرن

بث تسجيلات لضابط يحث إعلاميين على إقناع المصريين بقرار ترامب حول القدس-(استمع)

Jan 07, 2018
2
لندن – “القدس العربي”: بثت قناة مكملين، المعارضة للسلطات المصرية، مساء اليوم الأحد، مكالمات مسرّبة، كان صحيفة “نيويورك تايمز″، قالت إنها لضابط مصري يأمر إعلاميين بإقناع الراي العام المصري، بقرار الرئيس الأميركي دونالد ترامب بالاعتراف بالقدس عاصمة لإسرائيل.
والمكالمات من ضابط المخابرات أشرف الخولي، شملت عزمي مجاهد، ومفيد فوزي، وسعيد حساسين، بالإضافة إلى الفنانة المصرية يسرا.
تسريب مفيد فوزي
تسريب حساسين
تسريب عزمي مجاهد

ا وراء الخبر- امتناع التحالف عن تسليح جيش الشرعية

Al-Jazeera Cartoon: كاريكاتير: الزر النووي العربي

كاريكاتير: الزر النووي العربي

A GOOD CARTOON BY EMAD HAJJAJ

نار وغضب العرب !

Saturday, January 6, 2018

الحصاد- مصر- القدس.. مكالمات تكشف المستور

عزمى مجاهد : حزين على العرب اللى مهزوز من قرار ترامب بالاعتراف بالقدس عاصمة لـ اسرائيل



PLEASE SEE THE POST BELOW (From N Y Times)

Tapes Reveal Egyptian Leaders’ Tacit Acceptance of Jerusalem Move

AN IMPORTANT ARTICLE

The N Y Times



Link

As President Trump moved last month to recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, an Egyptian intelligence officer quietly placed phone calls to the hosts of several influential talk shows in Egypt.
“Like all our Arab brothers,” Egypt would denounce the decision in public, the officer, Capt. Ashraf al-Kholi, told the hosts.
But strife with Israel was not in Egypt’s national interest, Captain Kholi said. He told the hosts that instead of condemning the decision, they should persuade their viewers to accept it. Palestinians, he suggested, should content themselves with the dreary West Bank town that currently houses the Palestinian Authority, Ramallah.
“How is Jerusalem different from Ramallah, really?” Captain Kholi asked repeatedly in four audio recordings of his telephone calls obtained by The New York Times.
“Exactly that,” agreed one host, Azmi Megahed, who confirmed the authenticity of the recording.
For decades, powerful Arab states like Egypt and Saudi Arabia have publicly criticized Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians, while privately acquiescing to Israel’s continued occupation of territory the Palestinians claim as their homeland.
Continue reading the main story
But now a de facto alliance against shared foes such as Iran, the Muslim Brotherhood, Islamic State militants and the Arab Spring uprisings is drawing the Arab leaders into an ever-closer collaboration with their one-time nemesis, Israel — producing especially stark juxtapositions between their posturing in public and private.
Mr. Trump’s decision broke with a central premise of 50 years of American-sponsored peace talks, defied decades of Arab demands that East Jerusalem be the capital of a Palestinian state, and stoked fears of a violent backlash across the Middle East.
Arab governments, mindful of the popular sympathy for the Palestinian cause, rushed to publicly condemn it.
Egyptian state media reported that President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi had personally protested to Mr. Trump. Egyptian religious leaders close to the government refused to meet with Vice President Mike Pence, and Egypt submitted a United Nations Security Council resolution demanding a reversal of Mr. Trump’s decision. (The United States vetoed the resolution, although the General Assembly adopted a similar one, over American objections, days later.)
King Salman of Saudi Arabia, arguably the most influential Arab state, also publicly denounced Mr. Trump’s decision.
At the same time, though, the kingdom had already quietly signaled its acquiescence or even tacit approval of the Israeli claim to Jerusalem. Days before Mr. Trump’s announcement, the Saudi crown prince, Mohamed bin Salman, privately urged the Palestinian president, Mahmoud Abbas, to accept a radically curtailed vision of statehood without a capital in East Jerusalem, according to Palestinian, Arab and European officials who have heard Mr. Abbas’s version of events.

Photo

As Palestinian protesters clashed with Israeli soldiers in the West Bank to protest President Trump’s move on Jerusalem, an Egyptian intelligence officer was quietly working to persuade Egyptians to accept the decision.CreditShadi Hatem/European Pressphoto Agency

Saudi Arabia publicly disputed those reports.
The hosts Captain Kholi called all heeded his advice, and most other voices in the state-owned and pro-government news media across the Arab world were also strikingly muted, even unemotional, about the status of Jerusalem. Such a response would have been all but unthinkable even a decade ago, much less during the period between 1948 and 1973, when Egypt and its Arab allies fought three wars against Israel.
Shibley Telhami, a scholar of the region at the University of Maryland and the Brookings Institution, called the Arab states’ acceptance of the decision “transformational.”
“I don’t think it would have happened a decade ago, because Arab leaders would have made clear they wouldn’t live with it,” he said. Instead, he said, preoccupied by concerns about their own stability, the Arab leaders signaled that — while they may not like the decision — they “will find a way to work with it,” and “with a White House that is prepared to break with what had been taboos in American foreign policy.”
Two spokesmen for the Egyptian government did not respond to requests for comment for this article. Captain Kholi could not be reached.
Television talk shows play a formative role in shaping public debate in Egypt, and Egyptian intelligence services often brief the presenters of the programs about messages to convey to the public. The hosts typically prefer to characterize the conversations as journalists talking to sources.
In addition to the call with Mr. Megahed, three other audio recordings of strikingly similar telephone conversations with the same intelligence agent, Captain Kholi, were all provided to The Times by an intermediary supportive of the Palestinian cause and opposed to President Sisi. The origin of the recordings could not be determined.
Mr. Megahed, in an interview, said that he had agreed with Captain Kholi based on his personal assessment of the need to avoid a fresh outbreak of violence, not on the orders of the intelligence service.
“I am friends with Ashraf and we talk all the time,” Mr. Megahed said. “Another intifada would be bad. I have no problem saying all of the things you have heard in that call in public.”
As for those who disagreed, he said, “We should have buses pick up all the people who say they want to go fight for Jerusalem and actually drive them to Jerusalem. Go fight if you are so tough. People are sick of the slogans and all that. I only care about the interests of my country.”
Two of the calls were with other well-known Egyptian talk show hosts. One of them, Mofid Fawzy, quickly denied taking part in any such conversation and immediately hung up the phone.
The other host, Saeed Hassaseen, who is also a member of Parliament, stopped returning phone messages and backed out of plans for an interview after a journalist contacted Mr. Megahed and Mr. Fawzy about the calls.

Photo

Lawyers in Cairo protested the American recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel while the government was trying to persuade Egyptians to go along with the decision. CreditNariman El-Mofty/Associated Press

The fourth call was with an Egyptian singer and actress known as Yousra, who could not be reached for comment.
The recordings all appear to match public recordings of their voices, and Captain Kholi’s talking points in each of the calls follow the same lines as his conversation with Mr. Megahed.
“I was just calling to tell you what our public stance is, so if you go on TV or speak in an interview, I am telling you what is the stance of Egypt’s national security apparatus and what it stands to benefit from in this matter of announcing Jerusalem to be the capital of Israel, O.K.?” Captain Kholi began one conversation, with Mr. Hassaseen.
“Give me orders, sir,” Mr. Hassaseen replied, according to the recording. “I am at your command.”
“We, like all our Arab brothers, are denouncing this matter,” Captain Kholi continued. But, he added, “After that, this thing will become a reality. Palestinians can’t resist and we don’t want to go to war. We have enough on our plate as you know.”
The Egyptian military has struggled for more than four years to try to defeat a simmering militant Islamist insurgence centered in the North Sinai, and Egyptian officials have sometimes accused Hamas, the militant Palestinian group that controls the adjacent Gaza Strip, of abetting violence against the government of Egypt.
“The point that is dangerous for us is the intifada issue,” Captain Kholi explained. “An intifada would not serve Egypt’s national security interests because an intifada would revive the Islamists and Hamas. Hamas would be reborn once more.”
“At the end of the day, later on, Jerusalem won’t be much different from Ramallah. What matters is ending the suffering of the Palestinian people,” Captain Kholi concluded. “Concessions are a must and if we reach a concession whereby Jerusalem will be — Ramallah will be the capital of Palestine, to end the war and so no one else dies, then we would go for it.”
All three recipients of his calls pledged to convey his messages, and some echoed his arguments in broadcasts. “Enough already. It got old,” Mr. Megahed told his viewers about the issue of Jerusalem.
In his conversation with Mr. Megahed, however, Captain Kholi added an extra flourish. He charged that Egypt’s regional foe Qatar and its ruler, Emir Tamim bin Hamad al Thani, were the ones guilty of collaborating with Israel.
“You also will say that Tamim and Qatar have secret ties to Israel. You know all that,” Captain Kholi told the talk show host.
“Obvious ties,” Mr. Megahed replied. “My pleasure. My pleasure. I will include it in the next episode, God willing.”