Thursday, February 16, 2012

Q&A: Nir Rosen on Syria's protest movement



Journalist who recently travelled around the country discusses the nature and goals of the opposition.

"Journalist Nir Rosen recently spent two months in Syria. As well as meeting members of various communities across the country - supporters of the country's rulers and of the opposition alike - he spent time with armed resistance groups in Homs, Idlib, Deraa, and Damascus suburbs. He also travelled extensively around the country last year, documenting his experiences for Al Jazeera.

This is the second in a series of interviews he gave to Al Jazeera since his return. Read the first part here.

Al Jazeera: What is the social background of the protesters?

Nir Rosen:
In much of the country, entire communities are involved in the uprising. It is difficult to generalise about their socio-economic backgrounds. The revolution is strongest in rural areas, the smaller cities and the working class, shaabi, areas of Homs, Damascus and Aleppo. But there are also many wealthy and educated activists in the revolution.....

AJ: What is the role of women?

NR:
Women take part in demonstrations, but the majority are men....

AJ: Are there different types of protests being organised?....

AJ: What happens at a 'typical' protest?....

AJ: What preparations are made for protests?....

AJ: Have protests been peaceful?

NR:
While most demonstrations are non-violent, by April demonstrators clashed with security forces, throwing stones or Molotov cocktails. In some towns or neighbourhoods they would attack security headquarters and other government buildings they associated with repression, such as Baath party offices or ministry of interior or justice branches.....

AJ: How do the opposition treat their injured?

NR: Hospitals are off-limits to the opposition. To avoid arrest, they have created an increasingly sophisticated network of underground field hospitals.....

AJ: How has the leadership matured during the uprising?

NR:
As the uprising gathered momentum during Ramadan, more capable organisers emerged. Activists throughout Syria established larger, more formal structures, to coordinate the various activities of the opposition. Often the leaders of these organisations were better educated and older than the activists on the streets. The Homs Revolutionary Council was formed in September. It has committees dealing with security and armed operations, media, demonstrations, medical, humanitarian, and legal needs. As of January, it was feeding 16,000 families throughout the province. Its leadership is elected and lives clandestine double lives.

Activist in other provinces see Homs as a role model and have attempted to organise themselves on a similar model.....

AJ: How can the opposition communicate without being detected?....

AJ: Is the opposition unified in their political demands?

NR:
There is a remarkable unanimity and consensus in their views on the struggle, the future and what is needed. This is in part because of their communication with each other but mostly because of the unique role played by Arabic language satellite networks.....

AJ: Who represents the demonstrators politically?....

AJ: How is the opposition financed?......

AJ: Do Syrians want foreign intervention?

NR:
[This response by Nir, if true, is most surprising. I hope that the leaders on the ground of the Syrian uprising are not that naive and gullible.]On the issue of intervention, as on most issues, it is impossible to generalise about ordinary people in Syria. Both sides like to talk about the "Syrian people" but there is no such thing. They are deeply divided. Naturally those who support the regime are opposed to any foreign intervention though they are happy to receive assistance from Iran and Russia.

Most opposition activists, fighters and supporters on the ground in Syria are in favour of some form of foreign military intervention. The older intellectual opposition figures who are well-known but not significant in this uprising are opposed to foreign intervention.

Surprisingly, the mainstream Syrian opposition on the ground looks to the West for help. This is despite decades of anti-Western attitudes and anger over issues such as Palestine and the American invasion of Iraq. And despite evidence of how disastrous the American intervention in Iraq was and the mixed reviews the NATO intervention in Libya has received.

Even Islamist leaders of the revolution look to Europe and the US more than they do to Arab or Muslim countries (with the exception of Turkey)......."

No comments: